League General Discussion Thread

[simon33]

@avner said in League General Discussion Thread:

Maybe I’m more skilled as a tactic and not as a strategy?

I think the opposite is important. ie. Tactics trump strategy. Patton said something like: great tactics can make a mediocre strategy sing but without the right tactics an excellent strategy can fail.

So I guess you still need a decent strategy, perhaps look at what other players do as Axis. Allies need to react a lot.

[aequitas-et-veritas]

@avner said in League General Discussion Thread:

Maybe my mistake is to often limit myself to responding to the opponent?

Yes, talk to us. Ask for a feedback, ask for advice, look into other games.

[axis-dominion]

@simon33 said in League General Discussion Thread:

@avner said in League General Discussion Thread:

Maybe I’m more skilled as a tactic and not as a strategy?

I think the opposite is important. ie. Tactics trump strategy. Patton said something like: great tactics can make a mediocre strategy sing but without the right tactics an excellent strategy can fail.

So I guess you still need a decent strategy, perhaps look at what other players do as Axis. Allies need to react a lot.

It is neither strategy nor tactics that is primary, but principles :)

[gamerman01]

Don’t play while tired (or drunk) - block out plenty of time without distractions - and there’s no substitute for experience…

Perhaps ask a player who’s had a lot of success to analyze one of your games and tell you what he would have done differently.

And don’t zoom in too much on Triple A - you need to be able to see a lot of the board at once!

[Avner]

Well thanks for the advice.

What is certain is that it is difficult to always apply the principles on the board.

Then maybe one is good in individual sectors but lacks the general vision (Rommel in North Africa even if perhaps someone else had to support him strategically …).

And rightly so many games are also lost due to distractions …

;)

[Amon-Sul]

sorry guys i missed out

what is the final conclusion on number of leagues, tables and games needed for individual or all play offs?

[Amon-Sul]

@amon-sul said in League General Discussion Thread:

sorry guys i missed out

what is the final conclusion on number of leagues, tables and games needed for individual or all play offs?

for 2021 league

[gamerman01]

It’s good you asked, Amon, others are probably wondering too.

There’s one league.
Four standings sheets - OOB 2nd edition, BM, P2V, and overall/composite.

8 games needed in BM to play in BM playoff
?? games needed in OOB to play in OOB playoff
?? games needed in P2V to play in P2V playoff

Number of games required for OOB and P2V will be determined around mid-year (like July) because then we will all know how much activity/interest there is in each of those. That leaves plenty of time for players to get the # of games they need to qualify if they want to play in those playoffs (about half a year)

Composite/overall standings is for everyone’s information, to help you size up your opponents and see where you stand overall. Standings within each version of 1940 A&A govern playoffs by version. Does that answer all questions? If not, please ask follow-up questions. I will update the official league rules someday, but this is the most hectic time of year for me.

[majikforce]

Question. The US is amphib assaulting the Phillipines but a huge naval battle has to occur in sz 35 first. After 3 rounds of combat the US wants to retreat.

1. Is this a legal move? ( I believe it is)
2. Triple A keeps crashing every time the US tries to retreat. Is this a bug?

Thanks for any help. Load the last posted game file if you want to see what I mean

https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/36495/oob-35-bolasgod-vs-majikforce-game-2/162?page=7

[gamerman01]

Yes you should be able to retreat to 34 and Triple A lets you select 34 and retreat, it just crashes after that point (for me also). Use edit mode to remove the units from both sides and to get the US units to 34

[majikforce]

@gamerman01 said in League General Discussion Thread:

Yes you should be able to retreat to 34 and Triple A lets you select 34 and retreat, it just crashes after that point (for me also). Use edit mode to remove the units from both sides and to get the US units to 34

Thanks Gamerman just wanted to check.

[Amon-Sul]

@majikforce said in League General Discussion Thread:

Question. The US is amphib assaulting the Phillipines but a huge naval battle has to occur in sz 35 first. After 3 rounds of combat the US wants to retreat.

1. Is this a legal move? ( I believe it is)
2. Triple A keeps crashing every time the US tries to retreat. Is this a bug?

Thanks for any help. Load the last posted game file if you want to see what I mean

https://www.axisandallies.org/forums/topic/36495/oob-35-bolasgod-vs-majikforce-game-2/162?page=7

what happens with the tranny (and the land units he carries) in that case?

destroyed, or can retreat too?

[trulpen]

Also retreats.

[Amon-Sul]

@trulpen said in League General Discussion Thread:

Also retreats.

with land units or empty ?

[trulpen]

The amphi will be cancelled, since the sz would still be hostile, so the land stays on the tr.

[TheVeteran]

Is there any interest in including Young Grasshopper Tournament Edition in the league ?

[OwenToo]

@bretters not likely, because that version of second edition A&A is designed to be played by teams, face-to-face, and finish in a one-day session.

[TheVeteran]

@owentoo
@owentoo well to me it makes a lot of sense to play for the league playoffs and if it’s being used for play offs why not regular league play ? Have you checked it out at all?

[axis-dominion]

@gamerman01 and now we should be tied!

[Karl7]

@axis-dominion

LOL! Dawg is King by a mile!

Whatever happened to Boldfresh? Stand up guy.