Okay YG, I am going to try and point out some of the points in our game that may affect either G40 Delta, Halifax or both. I will also try to cover what I think are the reasons for the overwhelming Axis victory. First the country that is most affected by the new rules:
UNITED KINGDOM : As stated before, G40 Delta and Halifax are not entirely compatible. On the round 3 UK choice, we basically gave UK “Radar” and the Commonwealth (CW) “Commonwealth Aid” which basically amounted to the CW getting 1 IPC cheaper non-infantry units for the rest of the game.
I think the UK, getting 35 IPCs per round plus objectives, did get a little over confident.
ALL COUNTRIES ROUND 1 : Using Delta, Germany, Italy and France chose Airborne Assault Troops.
Russia, Japan, USA, UK and CW chose Wartime Production.
GERMANY ROUND 1 : I am not covering the land attacks as those are fairly standard and don’t really effect what happened with the UK. I will list the sea battles, what Germany moved, the results and German losses. Germany purchased 1 carrier, 1 destroyer, 1 sub.
Sea Zone 111 : 1 sub SZ 124, 1 BB SZ 113, 1 ftr Norway, 1 Stuka W Germany, 1 Bomber Germany. UK NO scramble. All UK ships sunk. Ger lost sub and BB. Bomber returns to W Germany, ftr and tac to SZ 112 to land on carrier.
Sea Zone 110 : 1 sub SZ 103, 1 sub SZ 108, 1 ftr Belgium, 2 ftrs and 2 Stukas W Germany, 1 bomb and 1 Stuka Germany. UK NO scramble. All UK ships sunk. NO German Losses. All planes return to W Germany, 2 subs remain in SZ 110.
Sea Zone 109 : 1 sub SZ 117, 1 sub SZ 118. UK NO scramble. Both UK ships sunk. Germany lost 1 sub. 1 sub remains in SZ 109.
UK ROUND 1 : they purchased a Minor Factory for Egypt, 1 mech for Calcutta and 1 fighter, 3 infantry for London. Since Germany wiped out all the Royal Navy around England, UK was going to move their Med fleet up there so they used the Malta fighter and SZ 98 tac to go after the Italian DD, TT in SZ 96. They killed them but the Italian DD took out the UK fighter. So UK moved the CV, CA and tac from SZ 98 to SZ 92, leaving the SZ 98 DD in SZ 94 as a block against the Italian fleet. The SZ 91 CA joined the Med Fleet in SZ 92. Gibraltar fighter moved up to London. All units in Scotland moved to London.
In Africa, UK moved 1 infantry from Sudan, 1 mech from Egypt and transported 1 infantry, 1 artillery from Alexandria all to Ethiopia. They destroyed the Italian army there with the loss of 1 infantry. UK tank in Alexandria moved to Egypt. Total units on Egypt: 1 tank, 1 infantry, 1 artillery, 2 ANZAC infantry.
Also, UK flew fighter and tac from India to British Somalia.
ITALY ROUND 1 : Italy purchases 1 transport and 1 infantry.
CA, DD and SS from SZ 95 and fighter from S Italy attack French ships in SZ 93. French ships sunk with loss of Italian sub. Fighter lands in Tobruk.
Cruiser from SZ 97 and fighter from S Italy attack UK destroyer in SZ 94. UK DD sunk with no Italian losses. Fighter lands in Tobruk.
Infantry and Artillery from Libya plus 2 paratroopers from S Italy attack Tunisia. Italy wins with no losses.
Army on Tobruk attacks 1 UK infantry in Alexandria. Italy wins with no losses.
Italian Battleship escorts 2 transports with 2 infantry and 2 artillery to SZ 98. They attack Egypt along with Italian Strategic Bomber from N Italy. All Italian ground troops lost. Bomber retreats to Tobruk. UK survives with 1 tank, 1 artillery.
1 infantry moves from Italian Somaliland to Kenya.
1 tank NCM from N Italy to Albania.
COMMONWEALTH ROUND 1 : Purchased 1 transport for Canada, 1 tank and 1 mech for South Africa and I think 1 infantry for Sydney.
SZ 106 destroyer attacked German SS in SZ 109 and sank it without loss.
SZ 106 transport moves 1 infantry, 1 artillery to London.
Moved fighter from Quebec to Iceland.
Transported 2 infantry from Sydney to Java.
GERMANY ROUND 2 : Chose Blitzkrieg for Strategic Advantage. Purchased 10 transports and 1 infantry.
Leads huge SBR raid against England. 2 Strategic bombers for the IC, 2 Stukas for the air base, 2 Stukas for the naval base and 3 escort fighters. UK sends up 5 UK and 1 French fighter for interceptors. Results are terrible for UK. 1 German fighter lost, 2 UK fighters lost.
Industrial Complex = AA fire misses, German bombers roll “box cars” resulting in 16 points of damage to the IC (Bomber 1 = 6 + 2, bomber 2 = 6 + 2).
Air Base = AA fire misses. Stukas get 3 points of damage on the air base.
Naval Base = UK rolls snake eyes. 2 Stukas killed.
Destroyer and Transport in SZ 112 takes 1 infantry and 1 artillery to SZ 91 and takes an undefended Gibraltar. This effectively traps the UK Med fleet in SZ 92. (PERSONAL NOTE: I (as Germany) am a little proud of this move. I almost didn’t see it.)
2 subs from SZ 110 and 1 sub from SZ 112 attack CW DD and TT in SZ 109. Both CW boats sunk with loss of 1 German sub.
All German units moved into position for attack on England. 2 infantry left at air base in Paris and 2 extra infantry at air base in W Germany (Airborne Assault Troops).
Border with Russia is weak. 5 infantry in Finland, 5 infantry 1 artillery 1 tank in each of Poland, Slovakia and Romania.
SOVIET UNION ROUND 2 : Soviet Union is neutral, but has been building mostly tanks and mechs for first two rounds at it’s front factories in Leningrad and Ukraine. They know Sealion is coming and are ready to reap the spoils in Europe.
UNITED KINGDOM ROUND 2 : Now they are taking invasion a little more seriously. UK has 44 IPCs to spend, however the first 16 go to repairing their Industrial Complex, leaving them with 28. The DO NOT repair the air base so no scramble. UK purchases 6 infantry and 1 fighter, all for London.
Tac from SZ 92 attacks German DD and TT in SZ 91 and sinks them then flies on to London.
Infantry and Artillery from Ethiopia transported back to Egypt. Mech in Ethiopia goes back to Egypt. Fighter and Tac from British Somalia fly to Egypt.
Egypt defenses are now: 1 infantry, 2 artillery, 1 mech, 1 tank, 1 fighter and 1 tac.
Not knowing what to do with their ships in SZ 92, they do nothing with them.
ITALY ROUND 2 : Italy only had 13 IPCs to spend and I just can’t remember exactly what they purchased. They did very good in the fact that they opened up 3 strategic objectives all on this round.
First they hit SZ 92 with 2 cruisers, 1 destroyer and the bomber from Tobruk. All UK ships were sunk with Italy losing 1 destroyer and 1 cruiser.
They hit Egypt with 3 infantry, 1 artillery, 1 mech and 1 tank from Alexandria, 1 fighters from Tobruk, 2 infantry brought in by transport and the battleship support. This time Egypt falls with Italy keeping 1 infantry, 1 artillery, 1 mech , 1 tank and 1 fighters.
3 infantry, 1 artillery from Tunisa plus 1 fighter from Tobruk attack Algeria. They kill the 2 French infantry (France moved their Morocco infantry to Algeria round 1) with the loss of 2 Italian infantry.
Italy attacks Greece with 2 tanks and 2 infantry from Albania, 2 infantry transported over from S Italy and 2 infantry para-dropped from S Italy. Italy wins with 2 tanks and 2 infantry surviving.
COMMONWEALTH ROUND 2 : Moved fighter from Iceland to London. All other CW actions did not affect the attack on London.
GERMANY ROUND 3 : Germany purchases infantry, artillery and tanks to try and shore up the eastern front defenses.
SEALION COMMENCES! While Germany only has a carrier and a cruiser to escort the transports, with the UK air base knocked out there is no fear of scrambling fighters so all remaining Luftwaffe units can be committed to England.
Total Attack force: 14 infantry (10 by transport, 4 by paratroops from Paris and W Germany), 4 artillery, 6 tanks, 4 fighters, 2 Stukas, 2 Bombers and 1 Cruiser bombardment.
Total Defense force: 13 UK infantry, 2 French infantry, 1 CW infantry, 1 UK mech, 1 CW tank, 4 UK fighters, 1 French fighter, 1 CW fighter, 1 UK tac, 1 UK bomber and 5 UK AA guns.
British Anti Aircraft took out 2 German fighters. Even with the “Radar” advantage, just a bad roll for UK.
The battle was long and grueling but Germany ended up winning. Surviving units were 1 German tank, 2 fighters, 2 Stukas and 2 Bombers.
Looking at the units involved, I think Germany should have had quite a bit more surviving units. I think in this case Germany ended up getting diced a little bad.
Okay, so there is how Sealion happened in this game. After London fell, Calcutta was almost no threat to Japan and they had a fun time of it in Asia stomping out the Chinese and small amount of British units that were left down there.
One major bad decision by the UK was their round 1 purchase. They should have bought more for defense of London. The increased amount of income I think does make the UK player think they are stronger than they really are. If they had built more defense in London, perhaps Germany would have failed in the invasion or decided to go Barbarossa instead.
Now on the SBR of London’s IC, both German bombers rolling a 6 is just plain lucky.
For the UK losing 2 planes as interceptors, that also hurt a little. Those planes could have meant 8 fighters defending instead of 6. They should have left their planes on the ground and let the bombers have their way with the facilities. After all, the Naval Base defenses whacked both Stukas.
One unusually good action was Germany taking Gibraltar and trapping the UK Med fleet. It occurs to me now that UK should have moved it’s SZ 91 cruiser to SZ 104 to prevent Germany from reaching Gibraltar. Of course, you might just not think of that. You would normally think that 1 transport would be kept for the invasion of England. So I wouldn’t fault UK too much for not seeing that ahead of time. I, as Germany, almost missed it myself.
With 2 cruisers and 1 carrier, plus possible planes on the carrier, some of Germany’s planes would had to be sent over the channel to clear the UK ships which means less German planes over London, although Germany did still have 2 subs in SZ 109.
Russia had a little fun as they attacked on Round 3. They slaughtered all the front line German troops taking Finland, Poland, Slovakia and Romania with good sized forces left. However, their Poland force was a little weaker than the others. I think that was just unlucky dice in that battle because the attacking force was similar to the others and the defending force was exactly the same as Slovakia and Romania, which were more soundly beaten.
Russia also took Norway, Yugoslavia and Greater Southern Germany. However, with England’s treasury, Germany had A LOT to spend in their Industrial Complexes in Germany and W Germany. Germany had already retaken Poland and soon eliminated the armies in central Europe.
Russia kept buying tanks and mechs, but they just couldn’t seem to keep up the offensive steam. After 2 or 3 rounds, Germany managed to push Russia back out of Europe.
Also, since there was no naval threat in the Atlantic, Germany still had all their transports. So they were able to also land a large force on Norway and move through Scandanavia. Germany also amphibiously invaded Leningrad. It took Germany until round 9 but they finally captured Moscow, which pretty much made Russia extinct.
This had to do with the US decision to go 100% after Japan. The thing is they did it all wrong. Instead of going after Japan’s navy with somewhat smaller task forces and doing more steady damage, the US just kept sitting back and building up a big fleet. When they finally did venture out to Queensland with the intention of attacking a good part of the Japanese fleet, then ended up leaving themselves open to the majority of the Japanese Navy because they didn’t take into account the positions of all the other warships and aircraft on carriers that were scattered throughout the South Pacific area. Most of them were within range of Queensland and they pounced, destroying that huge US fleet. Japan lost all it’s smaller vessels but did survive with 2 battleships and 3 carriers plus their planes. In one fell swoop, the US Navy was reduced to something like 1 carrier, 1 cruiser, 2 destroyers and 1 sub.
Also, on a couple of occasions, the US player led amphibious assaults on islands which were successful but ended up exposing their transports with little or no protection. This of course ended up with large US land forces being stranded on islands. (New Guinea and Hawaii)
What’s more, by the time this big naval battle happened, Japan was making a lot of money because of their success in Asia. They could not only match US builds but exceed them. There was just no way for the US to regain momentum in the Pacific.
I think the US should have been more aggressive against Japan. They would have taken losses, but so would have Japan. Maybe they could have at least made things more even.
So while our game ended up in an overwhelming Axis victory due in large part to poor choices by our Allied players, there is one thing that might be a flaw in the idea of having a single UK economy. Basically, if London falls, the Axis have a much easier time of it.
A = It makes the US decision much harder. If they go all after Japan, it leaves Germany alone to deal with only Russia. If the US goes after Germany, depending on how long it takes them to liberate London, Japan has a free hand to romp all over the Pacific and Asia.
B = If London falls, Calcutta becomes neutralized. Makes things a lot easier for Japan.
C = If London Falls, Italy is sure to grab Egypt and rule the Med. However, the Commonwealth could cause some problems for them in Africa. That also depends on whether S Africa is UK or Commonwealth.
However, if London doesn’t fall, UK could really cause a lot of problems for the Axis with the larger income. Then they, like the US, have to decide just where they want to put their income: against Germany or Japan.