Find league opponents here

[Karl7]

@Karl7:

OK, here is the deal:

First person to PM gets to play my allies for +20.  This is not a bid, just an offer of a game at that bid.

Happy 2015 league!

And remember:

[KILL! KILL! KILL!/size]

Wow, and it’s Mr Roboto off the mark for my first league 2015 game!

Well done sir.

[Karl7]

@Karl7:

@Karl7:

OK, here is the deal:

First person to PM gets to play my allies for +20.  This is not a bid, just an offer of a game at that bid.

Happy 2015 league!

And remember:

[KILL! KILL! KILL!/size]

Whoops, there has been some confusion, my offer is that I will play the Allies at +20.

That is too high for Mr. Roboto.  Any other takers?  PM me.

Wow, and it’s Mr Roboto off the mark for my first league 2015 game!

Well done sir.

[axis-dominion]

You can count me in.

[axis-dominion]

Karl is wanting a mic in egypt as part of his 20 bid…I’m really hesitating on this as it seems too powerful. Anyone have any experience going against such a bid or any thoughts on this?

[Karl7]

It’s an interesting bid.  An mic gives the UK a jump on fortifying Egypt at the expense of first turn fire power

[DizzKneeLand33]

In the rules (Europe is what I’m looking at), “Industrial Complexes and Bases (Facilities)” are listed separately from Units in the purchase phase (pages 27 and forward).  So, an IC purchase with a bid seems like it’s not a unit, but I’ve seen others who think otherwise.

Then again, if you were playing 1 upt for the bid, the UK could just as well place units in Alexandria, Egypt, and AES, and then just spend the 12 IPC’s on turn on for the complex (the bid placement is the same as getting to place 3 units on turn one in Egypt, if that makes sense).  So, it could be worked that way.

Now, placing units in Alexandria and AES while also placing the factory in Egypt – well, that would be an overload to the spirit of the 1 upt rule imho, but I don’t think there’s an official rule one way or the other?!  Interesting idea Karl, that’s for sure!

[Karl7]

@DizzKneeLand33:

In the rules (Europe is what I’m looking at), “Industrial Complexes and Bases (Facilities)” are listed separately from Units in the purchase phase (pages 27 and forward).  So, an IC purchase with a bid seems like it’s not a unit, but I’ve seen others who think otherwise.

Then again, if you were playing 1 upt for the bid, the UK could just as well place units in Alexandria, Egypt, and AES, and then just spend the 12 IPC’s on turn on for the complex (the bid placement is the same as getting to place 3 units on turn one in Egypt, if that makes sense).  So, it could be worked that way.

Now, placing units in Alexandria and AES while also placing the factory in Egypt – well, that would be an overload to the spirit of the 1 upt rule imho, but I don’t think there’s an official rule one way or the other?!  Interesting idea Karl, that’s for sure!

Gamer told me Mics were units for bid purposes.  Although that may have been just an off hand comment rather than a informed “ruling.”

Anyhow, yeah, I am not so sure how much impact a Mic would be.  As I say you are exchanging first turn units for longer term production power.  Which would lend to the long term UK control of the middle east remains to be seen.

[MrRoboto]

I’m playing as Allies+18 against JuanSpain right now and he allowed me to bid a factory in Egypt.

He eventually captured Egypt in turn 3, but not before having received -70 TUV, split among 2 battles with Italy/Germany and immediately losing egypt to UK again.

Personally I would not grant my opponent a factory in Egypt as a bid because I don’t consider myself strong enough to overcome it.

But that’s just my opinion. At the end you have to decide how confident you are to still win the game.

[Karl7]

Well Axisdominion is a much stronger player than I, so I hope it won’ scare him too much!  :lol:

[gamerman01]

Facilities are valid bid units because they are “units”, and the league bidding rules only talk about bidding “units”.  Also, there is no express league rule against bidding facilities.

I immediately see two advantages to using 12 of the bid for an Egypt complex, instead of bidding ground forces with that 12 and then building a complex UK1:

1. You could build naval into 98 or 81 on UK1
2. You can build more on London UK1 because you’re not spending 12 on the minor.

Otherwise, building 12 IPC’s worth of units in Alex, Egypt, and/or Sudan is more effective anyway.

[gamerman01]

I would be happy if my opponent wanted to spend 12 or 15 on a facility with the bid, because I think in every case that would be suboptimal

[gamerman01]

Although, here’s an interesting one.  You could build a minor on Queensland with the bid.  Still, gimmicky and suboptimal.  But interesting, since ANZAC starts with only 10

[Karl7]

@Gamerman01:

I would be happy if my opponent wanted to spend 12 or 15 on a facility with the bid, because I think in every case that would be suboptimal

Wow!  The league champion weighed in!  Maybe I should try to change my bid….  :lol:

[gamerman01]

:-D

But hey, there’s always the intimidation factor, Karl.  Sounds like Mr. Roboto would be intimidated by that bid.  The surprise and intimidation factor is worth something.  Could even be game winning.

[MrRoboto]

well to be fair, I wouldn’t (yet) give my Allies opponent +18 either, since a sub and 4 inf around egypt seems quite strong imho.

There is one more thing, though. With a factory you can choose to spend all of your starting IPC in Egypt immediately. If germany declares war on Russia G1 and builds land only, it might be valid and that would be a strong fortification.

[gamerman01]

@MrRoboto:

well to be fair, I wouldn’t (yet) give my Allies opponent +18 either, since a sub and 4 inf around egypt seems quite strong imho.

There is one more thing, though. With a factory you can choose to spend all of your starting IPC in Egypt immediately. If germany declares war on Russia G1 and builds land only, it might be valid and that would be a strong fortification.

Right, but I was comparing it to putting 12 IPC’s of units there immediately, which is faster than building them there UK1

[DizzKneeLand33]

Okay, it’s time….

League me.  2015 Style.  8-)

[Jennifer]

There are 4 hours left in the 2014 league.

Just a head’s up.

[Karl7]

Ok, any one else want to play me as the allies at 20?

PM me if so.

[MrRoboto]

Alright guys, looking for opponents. 70 games is the threshold to be beat :-)