League General Discussion Thread

[simon33]

Wow, no one has noticed that bug before. It isn’t even in the notes. I guess we all knew it was illegal and never attempted it.

[CaptainNapalm]

@simon33 I was shocked not to find it in the notes, as well!

[CaptainNapalm]

@simon33 Is this the place to get an official ruling, or is there such a thing? It is a league game.

[simon33]

We can @gamerman01 for an official ruling. Normally you’d probably post in the League Discussion Thread.

But is the other player really arguing this point? It’s clear in the rules.

[CaptainNapalm]

@simon33 He said he has done it before, so just wants an official ruling before changing his buy and/or placement.

[Panther]

I have moved the discussion to the League Thread. The OOB rules are chrystal clear, as pointed out.

[Avner]

Ok. Thanks

[gamerman01]

@CaptainNapalm said in League General Discussion Thread:

Can the UK place a factory on Persia, the same turn they move into it?

Triple A allows it.

The rules state “Place any new facilities in an eligible territory you have controlled since the start of your turn.”

So, my opponent and I would like an official ruling.

Right, it’s a tripleA bug. No power can ever build a facility in a territory that they did not control at the start of their turn.

[Sovietishcat]

@Adam514 I have Korea controlled by USA, I want to reinforce it with the Amur stack, but triplea wants me to DOW first? Is this normal or a glitch from the system, I am using the latest version on this game.

[Adam514]

@Sovietishcat said in League General Discussion Thread:

@Adam514 I have Korea controlled by USA, I want to reinforce it with the Amur stack, but triplea wants me to DOW first? Is this normal or a glitch from the system, I am using the latest version on this game.

In BM any nation needs to be at war with the original owner of the territory they want to move into, so you need to DOW as Russia to enter Korea, even on NCM. Or else that would force Japan to DOW on Russia if they want to take Korea back which doesn’t make sense.

[simon33]

In g40, that would also apply. If ussr is not at war with Japan, it can’t move into allied controlled territories on the pacific map, regardless of the state of war in Europe.

[Sovietishcat]

@simon33 and @Adam514 thank you very much!

[Sovietishcat]

@Adam514 @CaptainNapalm , I need you help once again! This one in PTV, in the new version, so N.Italy was left alone ( no units in the territory ) so I took it with one inf, but the axis player has planes in S.Italy which has an airbase, Triplea gave him the option to land scramble, but in the notes, It mentiones that land scramble can only happen if there is a land unit in the territory, is this a triplea bug or I am wrong. Thank you.

[aequitas-et-veritas]

Where do I find the Tech Tree or Tech Chart for a BM3 Game?

[Adam514]

@Sovietishcat The game gives you the option of scrambling in that situation, but even if you do scramble N Italy will still be taken without a fight and the planes will go back to their airfield.

[aequitas-et-veritas]

Never mind, got it alltready!

[FMErwinRommel]

Germany loses opening battle to France. Battle calc said 97% win. Should I just concede now? Anybody ever play thru when this happened to you? Also, lost BB but no planes against UK fleets. Retreated 3 tanks and can shift troops from Germ. Sank Canadian fleet. But no Vichy or cash bonus, and will delay and/or weaken move on Russia, which will likely be fatal.

[aequitas-et-veritas]

@FMErwinRommel play on a full round. See what happens with your J move and how your opponent react and what he does. See how Italy plays out and the decide wether you continue or concede.

GL

[AndrewAAGamer]

@FMErwinRommel said in League General Discussion Thread:

Germany loses opening battle to France. Battle calc said 97% win. Should I just concede now? Anybody ever play thru when this happened to you? Also, lost BB but no planes against UK fleets. Retreated 3 tanks and can shift troops from Germ. Sank Canadian fleet. But no Vichy or cash bonus, and will delay and/or weaken move on Russia, which will likely be fatal.

Against equal Players I have never seen the Axis come back from a failure to take France on G1.

[simon33]

I’ve played on but I don’t think I’ve ever won. When it happened against Adam514 I conceded right away.