League General Discussion Thread

2025 League rules have been updated from 2024.

There are only a couple sentence structure corrections, and proper links provided for the rankings, and that the BM and PTV rules are now located in their respective discussion threads and not on a dedicated pinned thread where it used to be.

Just remembered, the one change being made is @Arthur-Bomber-Harris proposal that the past year champion and runner up are automatic 1 and 2 seeds for the playoff, assuming of course they enter. After that, lifetime ELO score at 12/31.

Thanks, @Arthur-Bomber-Harris , that is a great idea.

@Daaras said in League General Discussion Thread:

@crockett36 It would be fun to actually put faces to all the forum names.

Easiest way is to watch @crockett36 youtube interviews. If the guys you play with in PTV haven’t done interviews, ask them or do one yourself, more is better

I also just miss actually rolling dice. I rarely actually bust out my boards anymore. I can’t wait for the kids to be old enough to battle lol

Ah, the swansong of the modern A&A player!
Good luck! My kids are grown now and are both capable. My son loves WWII so much he watches World at War documentaries with me (and is much, much wiser for it). Got him to play Zombies with me twice, even helped him win, and have Classic set up in the basement.

He pondered R1, got stressed out, and quit. Yes I told him not to worry about winning, yes I told him I’d hold back.

You do want someone you see all the time, obviously. 🤜🤛

@crockett36

Thank you for the suggestions you put thought into. January is the time for league rule changes, yes.
It is intriguing to consider different “flavors of the year”, but

“No” to standard bids set.
Individual player game by game bids are preferred because of individual and unique player strategies, it changes up the game, sometimes a LOT (you mentioned stale). It would actually be more stale if the starting set up was largely dictated to everyone for a year. Guard rail not needed, inexperienced player can just look at what the successful players bid

Players can agree to almost any modification for their game, so all kinds of customization and fun is allowed, and this is true even in the playoffs. But this is game by game so that everyone can count on the standard, out of the box experience without having them altered uninvited by others

If you have some consensus with multiple other league members on a change, or depending on the nature of your change, it is certainly possible to effect a change in rules. I give the people what they want, and I don’t think your suggestions so far will be welcomed by the majority. I reconsider if some of you start to coagulate

@axis-dominion said in League General Discussion Thread:

yes plz keep it stickied

Just the ol’ switcheroo…

The link to the old rankings is in the League Rules, under #3 “Scoring/Playoffs”
As is the link to the current ELO

I am excited to tell you we may have an influx of Axis & Allies players to the league in coming days. There is a group who really like playing Classic, and they are welcome in the league.

Yes, that’s right, for the first time probably ever, A&A.org league will have a section for Classic. They are looking forward to having ELO ratings, league rules and moderation, and playoffs. There is an 8 man tournament starting right now, and those game results will be recorded for them, of course in their own tab. Hopefully several will start playing in the league and some more momentum come with them.

Or the whole thing may not get as far off the ground as the Jan 1986 Challenger, but I wanted to tell you the news. A couple of the guys @Martin @elche are already league regulars.

And of course, it gives you all the opportunity to return to the roots. If you ever had the classic board game, you will love how it looks in Triple A, it is fantastic. And @The_Good_Captain is an absolute ace with the Classic rules and all its versions and variants. If you ever play Classic in any capacity online or with your friends/family, you have a resource.

I played a couple games of classic a year ago at @elche 's nudging and I’m glad I did. I am participating in the tournament (in the tournament section) so will be involved a bit with these guys.

Please prepare to welcome some new blood, even if none of them touch G40

Objection sustained, and thanks for another thoughtful post.

So I think I understand your sentiments, and it’s difficult to respond really well to all that so I’ll do it in summary of the history through my eyes.

1. We played Out of the Box to death when it came out. G40 was a very, very hot Axis and Allies product. Many more territories and zones, more playable powers, new units, airbases and naval bases, dual victory conditions. Mind blowing.

2. Many of us certainly couldn’t wait until the game was polished up. Larry wanted us all to go ahead and play earlier iterations and give feedback. So we played a lot of games before it was even done.

3. When the game was finished and done tinkering, we had yet another “new” version of the game. Like there was a major complex in Berlin now, and a minor in Ukraine that wasn’t there before. Exciting changes, but coming from the source, not from us, so it was global (pardon the pun).

4. In 2013 league players completed 619 games of G40
   2014 was 550
   2015 was 444
   2016 was 487, and this was the first year BM was played.
   2017 was 403
   2018 was 451
   2019 was 367
   2020 was 365 - COVID bump
   2021 I started tracked each version separately

OOB was down to 51
PTV 87
BM 201
Total 339 COVID still a factor

2022
OOB 30
PTV 38
BM 153
Total 221 Back to work LOL

2023
OOB 53
PTV 49
BM 118
Total 220

2024
OOB 53
PTV 83
BM 85
Total 221

5. So it is very clear that all of us big boys love “new, shiny” and enjoy it very much for a time, and it starts to get too familiar, or… stale.

Each of the versions started out very exciting because it was a significant twist on the much loved G40 game, and a mod that was widely loved and accepted as having

To your last statement,
Eliminating the small nagging skin tags is what started Balanced mod, for the most part, but I agree with you that the BM team went ahead and added a bunch of stuff to modify the game to be what they thought people would love most.

You are saying do a modification of OOB that is much smaller in scope that doesn’t add a bunch of features, it stops after fixing a few problems.

OK, that makes sense. And are you asking the league to come up with that fix, and maybe change it every year to mix it up? That does sound really cool and I would do it except then we’ve departed from actual out of the box as soon as we change one thing.

I’m not intending to make a closing argument, I’m putting facts and thoughts out there for discussion.