Historical Boardgames sponsored BATTLE OF THE AGES Tournament

[Panther]

@Veqryn:

Just in case anyone can’t remember how Revised rules are different from the ‘modern’ AA50 / 1942 rules, here is a brief list of differences:

Major Differences Between ww2v2 REVISED and ww2v3 AA50 / Spring1942
…

Thank you so much, Veqryn. This is very helpful, as AA50 was the beginning of my “A&A-Life”, so I never played Revised.
:-)

[Hepps01]

Helpful, but to late for me.

After looking at the map I am conceding my game to Bacala.  Too many early mistakes and losses based on information I was not aware of (my own fault).

Good game Bacala.  Very well played.

As a suggestion…. Perhaps for future rounds instead of making the opponent selection completely random based on the preceding rounds outcome…there should be some allowance for player experience. If players have a wealth of experience on a specific game perhaps it would make sense to only pair them with opponents who also have played the game before.  From first hand experience playing some one who is already experienced on a map was pretty funny (sad) and I’m not sure either of us enjoyed or were richer for the experience.

[Panther]

NWO: What are the victory conditions?

[Veqryn]

@Hepps01:

As a suggestion…. Perhaps for future rounds instead of making the opponent selection completely random based on the preceding rounds outcome…there should be some allowance for player experience. If players have a wealth of experience on a specific game perhaps it would make sense to only pair them with opponents who also have played the game before.  From first hand experience playing some one who is already experienced on a map was pretty funny (sad) and I’m not sure either of us enjoyed or were richer for the experience.

Point taken
however, I do not know who is good at what map, or just how good they are.  I don’t think the last 3 maps get much of any play, so i’m not too worried about it for the last maps.

@P@nther:

NWO: What are the victory conditions?

Surrender.

[Bacala]

Hi Veqryn,

Nice tournament. I won both my games, looking forward to round 3.

Greetings,

Bacala

[Veqryn]

@Veqryn:

Round 2 Matchups (this is for NEW WORLD ORDER)

ice
vs
Wassmuss

Ajmdemen
vs
lalapalooza

soulfein
vs
Gekkepop

P@nther
vs
pug6000

Admetus
vs
wirkey

Hepps01
vs
Bacala

Noll
vs
kabloom

Make_It_Round
vs
U-505

AmorphousCube
vs
SantaClaus2

moilami
vs
Odonis

Most Holy
vs
Nothing to see here

alexgreat
vs
Gargantua

Eskander
vs
DeadTom

Funcioneta
vs
Narushima

Veqryn
vs
seththenewb

Somehow had Santa twice and Garg missing.  Corrected.

Garg, you and alex are playing.

[soulfein]

hi veq, my nwo game is over, axis (soulfein) won vs allies (gekkepop)

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28738.30

still 2nd round in nap game.

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28697.15

[soulfein]

hi veq, well that nap game went really fast after 2nd round.

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28697.30

coalition (soulfein) won against carolingians (odonis)

waiting for 3rd round

gl hf

[pug6000]

@Hepps01:

As a suggestion…. Perhaps for future rounds instead of making the opponent selection completely random based on the preceding rounds outcome…there should be some allowance for player experience. If players have a wealth of experience on a specific game perhaps it would make sense to only pair them with opponents who also have played the game before.  From first hand experience playing some one who is already experienced on a map was pretty funny (sad) and I’m not sure either of us enjoyed or were richer for the experience.

I have a different opinion.
First I have a “newbie” opponent, who gives me much more contra than nearly all other players on that map.
Second there are 5 different maps. Everyone knows one or 2 maps better than his opponent. And when you are new to the first you may be expert in map 3. Who shall we pair you with in that round? It’s Swiss system.

[Veqryn]

@pug6000:

First I have a “newbie” opponent, who gives me much more contra than nearly all other players on that map.

This is one of the most awesome things to have happen in this tournament. 
U-505, with no prior experience on napoleonic empires, is really giving Pug (probably the reigning champion at the map, if there was such a thing) a fight, and its not even close to over at round 9.
Probably my favorite game to watch.

Other exciting developments include my new-found liking of NWO.  >:)

[lalapalooza]

Just an update:

Noll was an early concession to me on Napoleonic Empires.

Ajmdemen defeated me after only a few rounds at NWO. He played perfectly and I wasn’t able to brush away the cobwebs in NWO fast enough.

Awaiting round 3!

[DeadTom]

Hi,

Gargantua hasn’t posted a turn in several weeks, and has said in another thread (the XDAP game) that he won’t be able to play for several more weeks. What should we do about this?

[Veqryn]

@DeadTom:

Gargantua hasn’t posted a turn in several weeks, and has said in another thread (the XDAP game) that he won’t be able to play for several more weeks. What should we do about this?

You have a couple options:

1. You could request that this game be declared over.  In that case, after your request, I will private message Garg with a final warning the he needs to start playing again.  If he doesn’t post within 3 days (or tell us when his next post will be, but within a week), then the game is over and you are declared the winner.  Garg can still participate in round 2 of course.

or

2. You can keep pestering Garg to post, and meanwhile enjoy your round 2 game.  (this is part of the reason there are 2 rounds going on at same time, so that if one game is slow, you can always play the other one while waiting)

or

3. You can ask Garg if he would like to let someone else play for him for a couple turns or rounds until he gets back.  If you take this route, you assume the risk that he will pick a player who is better than you.

unlike other games, like global, there isn’t that much to calculate in Napoleonic empires.  there is no air, and the ships only move 2, and the ground only 1 or 2, so nothing too crazy can happen.  with no team members to consult, these turns should be moving pretty fast, and be pretty easy to do.

[DeadTom]

Option 3 sounds good. At least then I’ll be playing. Unfortunately, both my round 1 and round 2 games are going slow at the moment. BTW, when does round 1 officially end? or will it just keep going until all the games are called one way or the other?

[Veqryn]

@DeadTom:

Option 3 sounds good. At least then I’ll be playing. Unfortunately, both my round 1 and round 2 games are going slow at the moment. BTW, when does round 1 officially end? or will it just keep going until all the games are called one way or the other?

well, all the games are past round 4 so far i think (or done)

most games have a winner around round 6-9

so it can’t take much longer

i guess i would declare a cutoff point a few weeks out, after i see that all NWO (round 2) games have started and are at least in round 2 of the game
(after the cutoff point, a judge can decide who wins [or request extra rounds be played if it is really tight])

so far, not all NWO games have been started yet
(i will send some pm’s to push people this weekend)

[moilami]

This is awesome tournament. I am having so big fun in Napoleonic Empires, and can hardly wait to play the WW I map  :mrgreen:

[Panther]

P@nther surrendered in BotA round 2 (NWO). pug6000 has won the war!

http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?topic=28724.msg1028452#msg1028452

[Gargantua]

I officially apologize.

I cannot continue in this tournament.  Dead Tom and Alex Great advance with a WIN.

There just has not been an option for me to commit lately. My entire life is consumed by work atm.

[Veqryn]

@Gargantua:

I officially apologize.

I cannot continue in this tournament.  Dead Tom and Alex Great advance with a WIN.

There just has not been an option for me to commit lately. My entire life is consumed by work atm.

Sorry to hear that.

Dead Tom advances with a win. 
However since your game with Alex never started I’m going to try to pair him with another person who’s opponent never showed up for round 2.

Hope you come back garg.

[lexgreat]

The game with me did start, Garg made one move, I made 2