scramble / submerge sz110?
submerge sz106?
HF
Find league opponents here
-
I disagree. UK/ANZAC are at war…with Germany and Italy, not Japan.
Of course, but again, only Russia has the split map political status in regards to neutrality. Krieghund has explained this.
2nd Edition, European Rulebook, page 38:
“When not yet at war with Japan, in addition to the normal restrictions (see “Powers Not at War with One Another,” page 15), the United Kingdom may not move
units into or through China.”This specifically states that the prior-mentioned rules DO apply to the UK in regards to movement with Japan.
No it doesn’t, because it doesn’t say UK is neutral with respect to Japan. It says UK flying over China or moving into it is prohibited without a DOW from UK on Japan.
However, the Triple A problem is not with China.
Again, I have confirmed this with Krieghund.
There is no restriction for Japan flying over Allied territories. UK is not neutral. There is no special rule for the UK territories and FIC like there is for China.If you still disagree, just take it up with Krieghund. He’ll set you straight if I haven’t already.
-
Also note that UK/ANZ may fly over Japanese controlled territories when not at war with Japan. The only restriction is China, which is the rule you pointed out. And as you can see, my #7 problem with flyovers specifically points out the China rule.
Again, thanks, but you’re wrong.
-
Okay, did a reread (I think I’m getting a law degree from figuring out the rules :lol: )
So, while the rules on page 15 apply to Powers not at War With One Another, only the Combat and Movement parts apply. The part I quoted was for Neutral powers, which can only be Russia and the US, hence don’t apply to UK/ANZAC, or Japan.
I rescend my statements. Carry on!
-
Sure thing, like I said, your comments are welcome
Yeah, the rules are about as complicated and easy to misunderstand as the Internal Revenue Code, or any other Federal or State laws for that matter, like you said. -
I did unearth an extremely rare scenario that is against the rules:
“Triple A will allow a player to unload a unit from a friendly transport during CM and take control of an undefended territory, even though an opposing player is able to scramble and or cause naval combat to occur.”
So the set up was, as the Axis, I had control of Gibraltar, with an airbase and a fighter. France, during CM, is unloading 3 infantry from US/UK transports, with none of their naval units in the SZ. I scramble. What happens?
Since it is France’s turn, Germany cannot sink a US/UK transport, as they aren’t a part of the CM. However, as France is initiating combat, and I scrambled, a naval battle occurs with 0 French units and 1 German fighter. France, while not losing any naval units as they have none in battle, cannot amphibiously land in Gibraltar, as they were not able to successfully resolve naval combat. No units are lost, but France should not be allowed to land.
I guess this situation could also arrise if a UK transport moves next to Italy with a French troop on board. If Italy buys a destroyer or plane, France would be unable to amphib anything.
-
That is a good point that has not been raised (and has not occurred in my own games) and I don’t think it’s actually extremely rare. So I will add it to my list.
You are simply not allowed to unload amphibiously from an allied transports if you have no attacking naval or air units. So if the defender scrambles or the sea zone has become hostile, in such case a combat move off the transports is not allowed. (per Krieghund)
So are you saying Triple A does/did allow the amphibious assault? (In your example with Gibraltar)
Just wanted to confirm - I will add it to the list in the meantime -
First come first serve: I’m up for a game, no tech, pure luck.
-
Looking for 2 league games (G40- no tech, 2nd ed.). Also, if anyone is interested in a G42 on the side that would be nice too…its been over a year since playing AA so I’m really shaking off the dust. :-)
-
Looking for 2 league games (G40- no tech, 2nd ed.). Also, if anyone is interested in a G42 on the side that would be nice too…its been over a year since playing AA so I’m really shaking off the dust. :-)
1942 - looking for a little nostalgia ey? :wink:
-
Looking for 2 league games (G40- no tech, 2nd ed.).� Also, if anyone is interested in a G42 on the side that would be nice too…its been over a year since playing AA so I’m really shaking off the dust. :-)
1942 - looking for a little nostalgia ey?  :wink:
No, not AA50- 1942, the new setup made official by Larry a few months ago Global 1942- its also on Triple A now. Interested???
-
lol Bold’s always a few steps behind
-
lol Bold’s always a few steps behind
not always for once I was ahead of you on AAA adoption :-P
yeah I’ve been so far underwater I have had no idea of a new g40 modification
-
I just wish there was time for a good old fashioned Roadrunner versus Wylie coyote shootout!
-
unfortunately Wiley always brings a knife to a gunfight
-
Looking for 2 league games (G40- no tech, 2nd ed.).��� Also, if anyone is interested in a G42 on the side that would be nice too…its been over a year since playing AA so I’m really shaking off the dust. :-)
1942 - looking for a little nostalgia ey?�� ��:wink:
No, not AA50- 1942, the new setup made official by Larry a few months ago Global 1942- its also on Triple A now.� Interested???
I don’t mind playing AA50-1942.
-
You’re about a year and a half too late, Noz, virtually everyone has graduated to G40 now on these boards. It will be difficult to find an opponent for AA50, but who knows
-
The Russians are red,
The French are blue,
Happy Valentine’s Day
To all of you -
The Russians are red,
The French are blue,
Happy Valentine’s Day
To all of youhaha 8-) :lol: nice rhyme man ;)
wait, I think that Karl could reply with simple
kill, kill, kill :lol:
-
You’re about a year and a half too late, Noz, virtually everyone has graduated to G40 now on these boards. It will be difficult to find an opponent for AA50, but who knows
questioneer mentioned he wanted to play the new setup of 1942. I don’t mind doing that. I won’t play 1940 until the house league version of the game is done.
-
Looking for a game……pm me.
Suggested Topics
