Global 2nd edition Q+A ( AAG40.2)

@wittmann:

, but only one each per territory, of course.

Yeah, I knew that part (and about the naval bases) but thanks for being thorough guys.   :-)

Please help me understand this scenario:

Germany takes moscow and achieves 8 VCs. Russians follow by immediately taking Volgograd, but then Italy takes volg back during that same round. Now it’s Germany’s turn again, does axis achieve the win? Is this considered “controlling any 8 european VCs for a complete round of play”?

I’d appreciate a quick, authoritative reply as I’m in the middle of a game and need to know before continuing.

No…the axis don’t win. They won’t fulfill the vc requirement until Italy’s turn.

Walker is correct - must maintain 8 VC’s throughout a full round of play, in this case Italy to Italy

Guys, thank you for the quick reply! So then the TripleA version of global 1940 2nd ed has implemented it wrong then?

Yes, TripleA unfortunately implements many things wrong.

What else do you know is wrong?

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1cS3hFwoBP0rWr3208jw1LAtCvHYa9Ji9uU8PwbCMIwM/edit

My comprehensive list is here.  Most of these are noted in the TripleA game notes now

I would be happy to answer any questions you have after reading this list

This is great. Thank you so much!

Hi guys - question re: Scrambles

scenario:

SZ 113 is being attacked by amphibious assault. A FTR and Carrier are brought in from UK, and transports carrying amphibious units are landing in Germany. SZ 113 is already occupied by US carrier as well. Germany scrambles 2 TAC from West Germany to defend SZ 113.

Now, do the US ships also participate in the defence against the scramble, or is it just the UK units?

Thanks!

Just the UK units.

Well that’s a dumb rule… So I could have an entire armada sitting off the coast but the scramble only attacks those units from one country? Yet another combined units gap in the rules!

Axis and Allies rules have always been that only one power attacks at a time.
The naval units are considered attackers.  It just feels like the USA boats should be defending because of the scramble, but it’s just the UK attacking those scrambled units - the scrambled aircraft are defending

If you forget to land your aircraft and a few turns passed…. do those air units crash n burn?

cow, it was uk pac and all you did was italy which had nothing to do with india or the entire pacific.  when i got back to the pacific with anzac, thats when i realized the tripleA error.

I am actually curious what the official answer to this is. Because the rules contradict. Also if we do land planes where do we land them? Adjacent territory or player choice? It also contradicts the other rule that removes unlanded fighters from the game.

It always crashed and burned in my games. You are the first person who wanted an official ruling so I am getting it.

When a player forgets to land fighters and ends the turn, are the fighters dead? If they are alive who decides where they land?

I would think it would be the opponent’s responsibility to point it out, actually.  Much like both players are supposed to look for all possible convoy damage on each collect income phase.  But if you’re playing with a buddy and you both like to play that way, of course that would be fine (you forgot to land them - they crash).

All aircraft are supposed to be landed safely if possible by the end of non-combat.  So not landing them, I would say is a rules violation.  Just as with any other rules violation, the opponent should point it out and it can be rectified, and then your question becomes irrelevant.

If someone moves a bomber out and forgets to noncom it, do you think that should crash too?  I’m sure the vast majority of players would agree that the non-combat phase is not really over until all air is legally landed (or crashed if a carrier couldn’t possibly pick them up)

You are diverting from the question.

It is a yes or no question. These things happen. People forget to roll convoys and only remember until a whole round later. Do you rectify that?

It is pretty simple question. Do fighters crash or do you rectify it somehow? What are the rectify rules? Opponent chooses where it goes or what?

First time hearing of these rectify rules.