I think Japan still would have invaded the Soviet Union though, if the Second Sino-Japanese War continued (the oil embargo only really happened once they invaded Indochina).
Other than that I agree with you. That would be curious alternate reality.
Well, Finnish politicians did quite good if we don’t mention those who before 1939 did their best to not buy anything to Finnish Defence Forces. I wish dearly those politicians would had been sent to the front line. To the front line in…to face the execution squad :D
However, Finland would of course wanted to stay neutral in WW2, like Sweden did. There was absolutely no point in declaring war to Allied nations. Even an idiot would had understood that.
Anyway, Germany gave Finland arms and troops in critical moments 1944 to stop Russians. I bet Germans did not have too much themselves. And what the Finns did? Threw Germans out of Finland and made peace with Russia. I am not too proud of that, though.
I am curious to know why they chose that Eastern Europe was to belong to Russia. How did Russia manage to negotiate that?
Hi Moilami. Thanks for replying: I wondered if you had an opinion on this.
I was so surprised to read that the US and UK gave up Esstern Europe to Stalin so early on. It was not even 44. I am disgusted and have no idea why they lay down so easily.
Shameful.
Lol, well said!
I can’t understand it either. It was Russia who had problems with Germany, and it was Russia who needed help. So how could they make such claims?
By the way, about that unconditional surrender - Finland had of course big problems with Russia, but Russia would had had to do a lot more to make Finland surrender unconditionally. Their major attack in Finland failed, partially thanks to Germany. Russia was not ready to push more troops and equipment on rather insignificant front and they were in a hurry to rush to Berlin, so Finland avoided occupation by Russians.
According to historians Jowett & Snodgrass, Mcateer, Lunde, and Alanen & Moisala, the Battle of Tali-Ihantala, along with other Finnish victories (Battle of Viborg Bay, Battle of Vuosalmi, Battle of Nietjärvi, and Battle of Ilomantsi) achieved during the period, finally convinced the Soviet leadership that conquering Finland was proving difficult, and not worth the cost;[16][30][1][2] the battle was possibly the single most important battle fought in the Continuation War, as it largely determined the final outcome of the war, allowing Finland to conclude the war with relatively favorable terms[16][31] and continue its existence as an autonomous, democratic and independent nation.[16][32] Finnish researchers state that Soviet sources – like POW interviews – prove that the Soviets intended on advancing all the way to Helsinki.[33] There also existed an order from Stavka to advance far beyond the borders of 1940.[17]
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Tali-Ihantala
Not even close to unconditional surrender. Finns has fought against Russians many times and know well that it would be better to die than to be conquered by Russians :-D
I am glad you looked into it. I always wondered how Finland got such a good deal compared to the other Axis allies. I can see how conquering your country would have been an unnecessary and costly diversion when the race was on to get to Berlin.
Exactly!
Wittman & Moilami,
@wittmann:
Hi Moilami. Thanks for replying: I wondered if you had an opinion on this.
I was so surprised to read that the US and UK gave up Esstern Europe to Stalin so early on. It was not even 44. I am disgusted and have no idea why they lay down so easily.
Shameful.
––That’s why I think that the word “POLITICS” with all of it’s possible deviations is such a vulgar word with a potentially awful meaning.
“Tall Paul”
Today, the 9th December, in 1940 a small but mobile British army broke through the Italian lines and converted what was to be a 5 day raid into a full scale operation that pushed the numerically superior Italian forces occupying Western Egypt back hundreds of miles and taking thousands of prisoners.
It was a fantastic feat as the British commanded by Archibald Wavell only numbered 30000 in Egypt and the Italians under Graziani 150000. It succeedly because the Italians were not at all mobile and the British were. The few Italian tanks were slow, under armed and mechanically unreliable. the British ones were fast Cruiser type ones and they also had some slow Mathildas, but so heavily armoured as to be indestructable to Italian anti-tank guns. The planes both sides had were biplanes, the Italians Fiat C32s and the British Gloster Gladiators.
It is largely because of this Italian defeat in December of 1940 that Hitler decided to send aid in to his allies in the form of a small Africa Korps under a certain Erwin Rommel in February of 1941.
Today, the 12th December, in 1942 Manstein launched Operation Winter Storm. It was the attempted relief of the besieged and still potent 6th Army (trapped with elements of 4thPZ and some Romanian units). Unfortunately for the Germans, Manstein did not get the necessary Panzer Divisions, otherwise I believe few doubt he would have accomplished a corridor to Von Paulus and his men.
Hoth was the 4thPZ Army commander and the right choice to lead the advance. With two PZ Divisions, the 6th and 23rd in the 47PZ Corps(later a third Division, the 17th, was added) he managed to get half way to Stalingrad, about 40 miles, before he was stopped on the river Myshkova by the 2nd Guards Army. All the while his left flank was covered by an Infantry formation, ABT Hollidt. At this point, Von Paulus could have ordered a breakout, but Hitler never gave permission, so his army sat within relief distance without moving.
For three more weeks Hoth pushed nearer to Stalingrad, but still no move was sanctioned and Von Paulus refused to disobey Hitler (and breakout), so Manstein’s and Hoth’s efforts were for nought.
Two weeks after invading Finland, December the 14th 1939, Russia was expelled from The League of Nations. Russia invaded Finland because they said they needed security for Leningrad, which was only 40 kms from the Finnish border.
The Russians were mightly humiliated by the tiny Finnish army, suffering far more casualties than they inflicted, despite having three times the number of men, thirty times the number of aircraft and one hundred times more tanks.
The conflict ended in March of 1940, with Finland having ceded 11% of its territory, but 30% of its resources. Russia had hoped to conquer all of Finland.
good post Witmann, I really apreciate that “on this day…” is kept alive.
Thank you. I try to post here or in General when a significant event/battle occurs as you know.
Does not take long.
Something happened on our birthday that I could write about, but how much do I write!
December 15th 1944:All Quiet on the Western Front.
At least it was on the Western(American) side, where in the Ardennes the snow lay thick.
December 16th 1944: Hitler unleashed his remaining armoured reserves in the West, rather than safe them to use against his mortal enemy in the East.
Two Panzer Armies, the 5th under the respected and highly able Hasso Von Manteuffel and the 6th under Hitler’s favourite and highly decorated Sepp Dietrich, shattered the calm of a quiet Winter in the lightly defended Ardennes to start what has become to be known as the Battle of the Bulge.
The plan was simple: take advantage of bad weather and reduced Allied Air Superiority to smash the best Germany could offer against a weak and surprised American Army(Hodges 1st)and reach Antwerp. I am sure no realistic German commander believed this even a possibility, but total surprise was realised and shock waves caused throughout the depleted Allied chain of command.(Many were on Christmas leave.)
The 5th Panzer contained the 47th and 58th Pz Corps: 2nd, 116 and Pz Lehr Divisions, about 250 tanks. The 6th contained the vaunted 1SS Pz Corps(formerly Dietrich’s command) under Hermann Priess and had the best tanks at the time. 1SS Pz had 80 and 45 King Tigers. The 12SS Pz 80 MK IVs and Panthers. Both Divisions counted 22000 men apiece.
Many Infantry Divisions were scheduled to fight alongside the Panzer Divisions and keep pace as best they could; none were mechanised and would find the tiny roads hard going.
The Southern shoulder of the planned attack, close to the Luxembourg border, was covered by Brandenberger’s 7th Infantry Army(for the most part, reconstituted Normandy Divisions).
The US Divisions standing in the way of this German juggernaut were from Middleton’s 8th and Gerow’s 5th Corps: 2nd, 28th, 99th and 106th Infantry Divisions, with a reserve of the
7th and 9th Armour. Most of the units were green or had been bloodied in the Hurtgen Forest.
To aid in confusing the enemy, Hitler added Operation Grief to the offensive. This entailed Germans dressing as Americans so as to capture important bridges and send units the wrong way. Otto Skorzeny, of Mussolini’s rescue fame, was given a mechanised Brigade of captured US equipment to spearhead this plan of Hitler’s. Some Paras were also dropped.
For the most part the Americans holding the front lines did a good job of slowing the German advance units. In places a platoon held up the whole advance, but by day’s end the Germans had broken through and were advancing, but behind schedule. Their greatest success had come on 5th Panzer’s front and not in the North on the 6th’s front, where the man expected to advance the furthest, SS Lt Col Jochen Peiper was duly frustrated by the traffic jams developing. His Division commander, aware of how hard manoeuvring would be in this terrain and weather, had allocated Peiper, his Pz Regiment Commander, the lead with his 100 tanks and intrinsic Engineer Company, with the addition of the Division’s motorised Infantry Battalion. Much was expected of Himmler’s former Adjutant.
December 17th 1939 the Graf Spee was scuttled at Montevideo after spending four days in its neutral port. Her Captain, Langsdorf, commited suicide.
The Graf Spee was a Deutschland class Heavy Cruiser, weighing 16000 tons, armed with 6* 11 inch guns and capable of 29 knots.
She had been at sea since September and had sunk nine vessels totalling 50000 tons.
On the 13th December she engaged three Cruisers, only one of them a Heavy one and although inflicting considerable damage to them, especially the Exeter, she too had taken almost 100 casualties and needed repairs.'Her Captain decided to go to the nearest port to start repairs, as he deemed Germany impossible to reach in the state she was in.
He ordered her scuttled as he believed reports of a build up of Royal Navy ships awaiting his sailing and thought to safe his crew from certain death. No such ships existed.
The Royal Navy breathed better knowing she was no more.
December 17th 1944. The Malmedy Massacre.
Peiper’s Spitze is spearheading the 1SS PZ Corps advance on 6th Army’s front. He is leading from the front, capturing village after village. Part of his KFG take the wrong road and capture 100 men of B Battery 285 Field Artillery Observation Battalion, after shooting up and destroying 6 of their trucks. The survivors were taken and shot at a field near Baugnez.
113 bodies were found.
Peiper was on his way to Ligneuville, where he understood an HQ was .
No one knows who gave the order.
The 1st SS PZ continued to advance. They had captured fuel at Bullingen.
Before I go off to the war games I want to say thank you to Wittmann for doing such a good job for me while I’m trying to win war games.
Dec 17 1941 In the Gulf of Sirte an Italian convoy bound for Lybia and escorted by the entire Italian Naval force (the battleships Littorio,Doria, Cesare and Duilio, five cruisers and 20 destroyers), commanded by Admiral Iachino, chances to meet a British convoy bound for Malta, with an escort under the command of Admiral Vian of six cruisers and 16 destroyers. The engagement opens at 5:40 p.m. after a prolonged ‘long range observation’ , but it only lasts a few minutes with no damage to either side.
Tanks S.A.
Hi SA!
On 19th December 1941 Italian frogmen planted mines on two Royal Navy Battleships: Queen Elizabeth and her sister ship, the Valiant, while sitting in Alexandria harbour. The frogmen were captured, but both ships were still damaged.
Both were pre-WW1 Dreadnoughts, commisioned during the war and the first to be fuelsd by oil, not coal. Like most older ships, they had had modernisation work done to them prior to WW2. They were proud ships that had seen action in both wars and were to see more. Neither was sunk, although both were put out of action for some time, the Elizabeth for 18 months.
@wittmann:
Hi SA!
On 19th December 1941 Italian frogmen planted mines on two Royal Navy Battleships: Queen Elizabeth and her sister ship, the Valiant, while sitting in Alexandria harbour. The frogmen were captured, but both ships were still damaged.
Both were pre-WW1 Dreadnoughts, commisioned during the war and the first to be fuelsd by oil, not coal. Like most older ships, they had had modernisation work done to them prior to WW2. They were proud ships that had seen action in both wars and were to see more. Neither was sunk, although both were put out of action for some time, the Elizabeth for 18 months.
Love the story, one of the best of WWII. I believe a tanker was also blown up spreading burning fuel in Alexandria. You do a great job on this!
@wittmann:
Hi SA!
On 19th December 1941 Italian frogmen planted mines on two Royal Navy Battleships: Queen Elizabeth and her sister ship, the Valiant, while sitting in Alexandria harbour. The frogmen were captured, but both ships were still damaged.
Both were pre-WW1 Dreadnoughts, commisioned during the war and the first to be fuelsd by oil, not coal. Like most older ships, they had had modernisation work done to them prior to WW2. They were proud ships that had seen action in both wars and were to see more. Neither was sunk, although both were put out of action for some time, the Elizabeth for 18 months.
Very interesting. I would be glad to hear more of succesful or brave actions by Italians in the war. What you wrote was the first I have heard.