Cool! I can’t wait! Keep going!
Axis & Allies Dunkirk
-
-
I ran it through this program (https://gptzero.me/) that detects whether writing was generated by AI. The Dunkirk post above scored a 100%. Given the controversy surrounding AI, I thought it would be best to ask the admin what their thoughts are on stuff written by AI that does not disclose that [it was written by AI].
-
@SuperbattleshipYamato
Interesting. What exactly inspired you to test specifically this text against AI generation. What made it seem suspicious to you?@FranceNeedsMorePower
Have you indeed prompted an AI to let it generate this text?Regarding Forum Policy:
I would not condemn this, rather say “Why not?” to any content that adds value to the topic this forum is about. Unrelated stuff however would be removed as spam - as usual. And of course we would not want additional almost identical or similar AI generated “Axis&Allies Whereever” variants to flood the forum.However, we are not going to test every posting against possible AI-generation.
In any case a user who posts AI generated content - for reasons of fairness and as we don’t want any bots - should indicate that in his posting. We could use a tag - “AI generated content” for example - additionally.
(@djensen - please let me know in case you have other ideas, @witt - any additions?)So, @FranceNeedsMorePower let us know, please …
-
Blimey! Madness.
I thought it was a very long post and must have taken a lot of time amd effort . Perhaps , alarm bells should have rung.As Panther has asked , Please confirm if this is the case @FranceNeedsMorePower
I am very worried about AI taking over the world, so would be good to know and have a policy or a little chat about it , if this post is not a human’s work.
-
I don’t fancy myself as an AI expert, but I “felt” that the writing style of the post was somewhat like an AI’s. Additionally, I’ve noticed that AI often speaks rather vaguely when talking about more obscure topics (like Axis and Allies), and many of the ideas here are written vaguely.
I agree with your guidelines.
-
@SuperbattleshipYamato i have no idea what is going on. I’m trying to read everything an get confused. Yes I did use AI I thought that was clear. But not all of it was I wrote something and pasted it into it and it added and removed stuff to make it better. One of my ideas is to use the D-Day map. I’m sorry for all the confusion. If you have any question ask me. I’m still confused through myself.
-
@Panther How would I tag it?
-
Well, you didn’t say you used AI anywhere. Otherwise, most people would assume that it was entirely written by a human. If you edited and wrote some of it yourself, you can obviously credit yourself as such.
I didn’t get the impression that you would be using the D-Day map. Maybe one similar to it, but not the same.
-
@SuperbattleshipYamato Sorry for all the confusion, ok so then I would get some credit. I just use AI to touch it up and add more ideas for example it came up with the idea that German ship can attack the evacuation fleet. I think everything is clear now right? It be a map like D-Day I said this at this spot “A detailed map of the Dunkirk region, including the beach area, town of Dunkirk, and surrounding countryside.” This would be similar to the D-Day map. So would I need to tag this as AI or no?
-
Well, a disclaimer would be nice. Since it’s not too clear how to tag it, I suggest you just explain this above. The part about Germans ships attacking the fleet definitely felt like one of the most “AI-ish” parts to me.
-
@FranceNeedsMorePower said in Axis & Allies Dunkirk:
@Panther How would I tag it?
Thank you for your confirmation. To be clear: All of this discussion is not about blaming you for having used AI in any way.
It is just the first time the use of AI (to which extent ever) has become obvious to a user (@SuperbattleshipYamato ) - and this is a new occurence on this forum.
Now the question has been “How to deal with it?” - and I have added a new related paragraph to our Forum Rules. See #14.
You add tags in your very first posting. There is a respective entry line at the bottom of the text.
Once you posted you can use “Edit” to add tags and disclaimer.
To save us some time I have already added a tag. -
P Panther referenced this topic on Sep 18, 2024, 7:37 AM
-
@SuperbattleshipYamato Welp looks like were good now. I’m going to start on a 1944 setup. Should I do early or late.
-
@Witt said in Axis & Allies Dunkirk:
Blimey! Madness.
I thought it was a very long post and must have taken a lot of time amd effort . Perhaps , alarm bells should have rung.As Panther has asked , Please confirm if this is the case @FranceNeedsMorePower
I am very worried about AI taking over the world, so would be good to know and have a policy or a little chat about it , if this post is not a human’s work.
In the delightful brightness of the far future, there is only AI.
About the near future instead, I’m guessing that virtually all board-games will be made by AI or at least mostly by it. The editors will just tell the AI the general concept of the game and the main game dynamics, and the AI will fill up the rest, creating the board-game itself and writing the rule-book.
And of course we will have the AI answering all our questions within 1 second in forum and elsewhere.
Maybe the new Axis&Allies we’ll be playing 20 years from now will be made by AI.
I’m curious about what AI experts like @redrum think about it though. Am I being too optimistic?
-
@FranceNeedsMorePower May 44. Before D-Day and Bagration. Not sure what happened in thr Pacific in the Summer of 44.
-
Agreed.
Summer of 1944 was when the Battle of the Phillipine Sea happened, destroying Japan remaining carrier force. Also Marianas Islands campaign (Saipan+Guam). Probably the last chance the Axis would’ve squeaked by in some way.
-
@SuperbattleshipYamato thanks . I was sure 44 was the year of Japan’s collapse .
Was remarkable it had held so much territory for so long.
I suppose the US needed the time to build the war winning materiel and steam from island to island . -
Yeah. after 1943 the US advance was more slowed down by logistical considerations rather than Japanese resistance.
Suggested Topics
