BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?

[bgugs]

@djensen
IPCs in the bank and IPCs being collected were taken into account. There was no counting of TUV but I believe they could estimate that as well

[djensen]

@bgugs Okay, I think the way @smo63 does it is first Victory Cities (but I’m guessing the above game was a VD tie) then it goes to territories controlled. Since this is known in advance of the tournament, then everybody is on the same footing and no need for a judge.

[bgugs]

Ya I can’t say for sure what the qualifications were for victory. But generally I think it came down to who was in a better position to win assuming neither side made fatal errors. I know in the game I played in we had moderators decide because we were running out of time. They decided the axis won because they were making about 20-25 more IPCs a turn, and Japan and Germany were both very powerful with Japan about to go up another 10 IPCs for India falling. So we didn’t achieve the victory cities but the moderators determined that we were in the better position to win the game

[Karl7]

@djensen said in BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?:

@Karl7 said in BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?:

Some random photos above. The one of us toasting was after the final game, which was a split decision for Vancouver. I voted for Tacoma but Juan and Joel were for Vancouver. Joel did not participate in the battle. That was a tight game.

Why is there voting for victory conditions? Why not use IPCs controlled or IPCs + TUV (which would take forever to tabulate)?

Joel, Juan and I agreed we didn’t want some gamey tourney conditions, and we felt there was enough time to finish the games or get them to an obvious point where one side would likely concede. Indeed a number of games were conceded. But we ended up having to call (I think) around four of the 9 games. So not too bad.

Anyhow, the guidelines Joel, Juan and I used to call a game was in one part subjective, i.e. looking at the game what side would I immediately be more inclined to play, and objective, i.e. who had more money, more victory cities and better overall strategic position.

Only one game was a split decision, the last one. I raised the issue because obviously you rely on human judgment which can always be questioned. Where you draw the line between arbitrary objective conditions vs more subjective conditions is a debatable balance and one for further contemplation.

[axis-dominion]

Could someone plz put names to these faces so we know who’s who?

[Karl7]

@axis-dominion said in BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?:

Could someone plz put names to these faces so we know who’s who?

Nice pic AD! You are a lion!

Yeah, I can do that. Here was the provisional roster:

[axis-dominion]

@Karl7 thanks karl! but I meant names and/or aliases to one of the pics with everyone in it, so we can know who’s who.

[Karl7]

@axis-dominion said in BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?:

@Karl7 thanks karl! but I meant names and/or aliases to one of the pics with everyone in it, so we can know who’s who.

Ah! Ok

Starting from left to right:
Kirt ?, BC
? Langer in blue, BC
James Wiens, BC
Damian Allen, Seattle
Richard Mullins, BC
Joel/Gargantua, Vancouver BC
Lennard Feddersen, Victoria
Karl/Karl7, USA, SF, holding Gargantua’s hand
Andrew, Renton WA.
Stephen Yu, Seattle, A&A.org handle: Patryn
Guy way back in purple shirt almost obscured is Bgugs, Brandon from Tacoma WA
Guy forward looking goofy in Canada shirt is Canuck12, also known as Kyle McEwen, Vancouver
Nathan Gayner, WA, A&A.org handle: Mill Creek
Guy way in back second to last to right is Ray Chacko, Idaho, USA
On end is Samuel Nadeau, Victoria BC
(Curtmungus not pictured)

If I’ve got anything wrong, let me know and I’ll change it.

There are some guys not pictured here as they were either Friday or Sunday only guys. This was taken on Saturday.

[axis-dominion]

very cool karl, I appreciate it! now we know what you and garg look like hahaha, not sure if any of those other names are in our league.

[Patryn]

@Karl7 @axis-dominion I am the Stephen from Seattle.

[axis-dominion]

@Patryn well cool!

[Karl7]

@axis-dominion

You going to pin my face to the wall and throw darts at it?

[bgugs]

Bgugs is from Tacoma

[Karl7]

@bgugs said in BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?:

Bgugs is from Tacoma

sorry. Why were you taking a ferry then?

I changed. What is your real name again?

[Karl7]

@Patryn said in BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?:

@Karl7 @axis-dominion I am the Stephen from Seattle.

thanks! changed

[barnee]

heh heh was more fun guessing : )

[bgugs]

I was taking a ferry back from the San Juan islands

[bgugs]

Also Brandon

[Karl7]

@bgugs said in BATTLE IN VANCOUVER! IT'S ON! Nov. 23-25. Who will survive?:

Also Brandon

Changed!

[CaptainNapalm]

@Karl7
Open challenge from Team Tacoma to Team Vancouver to continue that final game that went to them in a split decision. It’s a shame we ran out of time. I have a photo of the whole map, and with Karl’s close-up of Europe, it should be easy to recreate.

PS After posting, it’s apparent that I don’t know how to post pictures on this forum.