@Cmdr:
Not really a “great” scenario if you ask me.
The submarines could attack the carriers, sink them, then submerge and watch the enemy fighters fall into the ocean without risk. Depending on the circumstances of where and when you attack.
But more realistically, when are you going to see this pop up? Also, why would you attack with the carriers? Just send the fighters in, get two hits and retreat now it’s 7 submarines vs 2 carriers, 4 fighters.
Oh no, it was not a question of 9 subs attacking 2 CVs, 4 ftrs.
My questions was, what is the better defensive buy. 9subs or 2 cvs 4 ftrs.
Of course it depends, but I suppose what DM says goes:
First get 1 DD 1 CV 2 ftrs in your battlegroup.
After that, add with subs, as long as the enemy can’t overwhelm your capital ships & ftrs with air. If you can get away with buying subs rather than capital ships - go for it (you get a better offensive capability that way, as a bonus)