@LHoffman:
Both institutionalized killing their own people… so pick your poison.
Here’s part of my point: how is killing “your own” people any worse than killing anyone else? They are all intrinsically the same.
Stalin “killed” at the very least 20 million on his own (which is a pretty universally accepted figure) and was the driving force behind the worldwide spread of communism, which has killed 149,500,000. The USSR accounts for about 60 million of those and China for 73 million.
http://www.scottmanning.com/content/communist-body-count/
This is about to become really political, if it hasn’t already, so I’m treading lightly here.
First, your source is highly misleading and pretty much completely wrong. The methodology is crap as well. I don’t have the time to detail everything, but it’s complete BS to pin all those deaths on Stalin.
Directly attributed deaths to Stalin are around 3 million from official Soviet Records. These are ordered executions, purges, and death during imprisonment. The truth is likely higher, and some suggest anywhere from 4 million to 10 million.
If you want to include famines during his reign, which the blame is also debatable, you’ll garnish some where around 7 million, maybe more if you’re feeling generous on what constitutes actual blame on what Stalin did or didn’t do.
All in all, most seem to suggest 15 million at a minimum, 20 million at a maximum (which you said, but that’s again part of the debate). That’s a fairly wide margin, though. Oh, and included in those death tolls are around 1 million German civilians and POWs. You know, from the war Hitler started.
And if you think communism is to blame, then why don’t you blame Karl Marx?
Hitler and the Nazis on the other hand maxed out at a total of 20,946,000 non-military deaths (but including POWs, civilian bombing and civilian executions). Which is likely much less than Stalin’s killing of only Russians/slavs in the USSR. The Nazi number does not account for the entirety of WWII and all deaths related to it, but even if we did, it would not approach the 150,000,000 of communism.
http://www.scottmanning.com/content/nazi-body-count/
So you’re telling me that while Stalin gets pinned for deaths that occur well after he’s dead and in completely different countries as well, the same person doesn’t use the same methodology for Hitler? Doesn’t even include the entire length of WW2, or the deaths caused by it?
Do I need to continue on how terrible your source is?
They were both evil. I am not sure how you justify calling one worse than the other when there is so much bad on both sides.
It’s a matter of a poll and simple opinion. And I was pretty damn sure that just about everyone would answer that the worst person to ever exist was Hitler.