AAG40 FAQ

@gamerman01:

Yo Vir!  kcd is right - I assumed that everyone knew that if Russia fell during Germany’s turn which comes between Japan’s and Russia’s, that Russia could not collect any income (including the 12 IPCs)!  Who doesn’t know that when your capital is down, you can’t collect any NO’s, you know?

Beijing is under Japanese control from the outset, yet China may collect income any time they have territories from which to collect income for.  Further, London is LITERALLY the capitol of India as well, yet India may collect income even though London may be under German control.  So there are situations where the capitol rule does not apply, specifically, when there are special rules involved.  The non-aggression agreement is one such rule, it is special, no other country has a rule like this, therefore, does it apply to the capitol rules or the special rule?

Hence the confusion!

Before attacking someone (and I think Vir saw it as not only an attack on him but on me too) I recommend calming down and attempting to see why there is confusion.  It’ll help you clear it up.  And no, the rules are not explicit nor implicit here, as Vir showed you in your own quotation.

Remember, there are people confused by many rules because Mr. Larry H. isn’t the worlds best explainer of rules, which is why this site and this thread exist!  If everything was black and white, the FAQ thread would only have the opening post, not 107 pages of posts (and counting!)

As for keeping you updated, no problemo Chummer.  I started a thread, hopefully we can all kind of post in there and keep the community appraised of what is being discussed…or not.

cough

anyone know which sz’s connect with which other sz’s in the Western Hemisphere?  I’m a bit confused about movement from Panama west.

SZ 64 connects to SZ 11
SZ 65 connects with SZ 28
SZ 66 connects with SZ 51

I would say, “I think” but Gamer would get pissed. =p

The essence of your question I THINK is you cannot get from SZ 101 to SZ 10 in one round.

Game occurrence was german fleet grabbing Panama and heading towards Australia.

So you are saying sz 52 does not border the edge?  This might make things a bit simpler but I will need to find a new road for ANZAC ships to the atlantic.

I prefer my ANZAC ships to take over convoy duty for my American ships…to be honest.

Page 32 in the Europe 1940 Rulebook answers all my Q’s about movement between boards and what sea zones are adjacent

Doh!  Thanks surprise attack, I checked both books and my website printout but of course missed it.  As it happens we have played it correctly based simply on lining up the creases in the boards.

@gamerman01:

@Cmdr:

@Vir:

Japan declares war on Russia, on Germany’s next turn they capture Moscow.  What happens to the 12IPC Russia would have collected for the DOW by japan?

Think it’s been asked and answered, the money is paid into the coffers immediately, not at the start of their next turn.  So Germany would get the 12 IPC, I think.

Wrong

Does anyone read rules anymore?  This is straight from the Alpha2 rules I printed out from Larry’s site.  Took me 30 seconds to find the paper and read it.

Under Soviet Union NO’s:
#4 “Collect 12 IPC’s, once, at the beginning of the turn following a declaration of war by Japan on the Soviet Union.  Theme: Recognized national emergency.”

Really, no interpretation or FAQ needed.   Just read the rules.  No offense meant, Vir, you just happened to be the hundredth person that’s asked a question that’s VERY clearly stated in the rules and is completely unambiguous.  Sometimes I think people don’t read the rulebooks anymore, they just learn how to play games from other people….  :-)

And Jenn, if you can’t answer basic questions correctly and you’re always saying “I think”, then why are you answering questions on the FAQ thread?

@gamerman01:

Yo Vir!  kcd is right - I assumed that everyone knew that if Russia fell during Germany’s turn which comes between Japan’s and Russia’s, that Russia could not collect any income (including the 12 IPCs)!  Who doesn’t know that when your capital is down, you can’t collect any NO’s, you know?

LOL…backpedaling that fast will throw out your back!  No sane person could look at your original post and conclude anything other than Russia gets the money.  You state “as fact” Russia collects the ducets at the beginning of their next turn.  I repost it above for your enjoyment, no mention of anything else.  A lot of berating for even daring to ask the question, good job on running an FAQ.  I think I’ll leave the “Official Rulings” to kreighund.

And just an FYI, one major reason we post questions here, that may have been asked, is that we have a dispute or feel there may be a dispute for a course of action we want to take, and we can point to the answer.  Don’t bother going on about searching, the function is barbaric, and results may have been superseded.

I was literally not “completely wrong” since I would have been just fine and correct ENOUGH if the Russian capitol was not under house arrest. =p  Since you want to be contrarian and keep picking a fight by slamming me in 14 posts over and over and over again.

As the only female on the boards, I reserve the right to not pick up a rule book or a print out of a rule book for every post I make.  Hence, I use phrases like “I think” to get peeps going.  Kinda hard to look through 108 pages of posts to find an answer too…should really have a locked FAQ-Answered thread with all the answers and none of the posted questions.

Righto then Gamerman help me with this, if I have a 1 transport in sz 75, and 1 transport in sz 58 and the enemy has 2 destroyers in sz 57. Could 1 destroyer attack sz 75 and 1 destroyer attack sz 58. My impression was that they could both ignore the transport in sz 58 and attack the one in sz 75 or attack sz 75 and end all Combat Moves there, but not both.

Am I right?

You are NOT allowed to build units in an IC built this round.

Haven’t found anything in the Rulebook.

Thanks, nice greetings from rainy Germany…

Pg 24 of the Europe Book - You can use an industrial complex that you controlled at the begginning of your turn.

@Cmdr:

As the only female on the boards, I reserve the right to not pick up a rule book or a print out of a rule book for every post I make.

Huh?  Are you saying that being female gives you the right to be wrong?  :wink:

Although I lurk and rarely post, I have to comment here…

According to my wife, being female not only gives her the right to be wrong but also automatically makes any “wrong” answer correct, thereby also making any male answers wrong.

@Krieghund:

@Cmdr:

As the only female on the boards, I reserve the right to not pick up a rule book or a print out of a rule book for every post I make.

Huh?  Are you saying that being female gives you the right to be wrong?   :wink:

Yes.

You don’t date much or are not married, are you?  You should know this rule, it should be tattooed on the inside of your eyelids.  This is the Platinum Rule, the Golden Rule being do unto others…yadda yadda.

@Pan:

Although I lurk and rarely post, I have to comment here…

According to my wife, being female not only gives her the right to be wrong but also automatically makes any “wrong” answer correct, thereby also making any male answers wrong.

You must have awesome relations with your wife!  Good for you, Pan!

@gamerman01:

:-)

btw Jenn and I have been PM’g, and we’ve always been on friendly terms, in case anyone’s wondering

I am friends with everyone except 3 people and all 3 of those people do not post here anymore. ^_^