• Who voted other? would that be Ditka?


  • IP, I am not saying that Alexander is a far greater general that Caesar. I give him a edge, just a slight one.  You, however, are giving Caeser credit for things he did not create and discrediting Alexander unfairly but calling his opponents “levies”, saying he only fought two seperate nations and dismissing the leader/generals he fought against.
    Darius’s army had Greek hoplite mercenaries in it. He had the elite “Immortals” with him. He had Elephants, tons of cavalry and scythe chariots. Alexander also fought in Egypt, he fought Greeks, northern barbarian tribes, Scythians, Thracians, Persians and Indians.

    The Celtic tribes in Gaul that Caesar battled were  certainly not all naked. In general they were poorly armed, not usually in armor, poorly lead and were not a well organized army in large scale battles. I’m not trying to take anything away from Caesar here I’m sure the barbarians he fought against were fierce. If anything I’m trying to draw
    similarities between the two, Caeser and Alexander.

    As far as the Corhort vs Phalanx is concerned, I never claimed the Phalanx was better
    That was a nice post about the two formations.


  • Ok but i have to add that i retracted the achievements under Caesar because they were actually part of the  Marian reforms. Secondly, i dont think you can dismiss both Vercingetorix and Commius the latter of which was a a former ally of Caesar and Rome. I doubt that Caesar would allow some ‘naked savage’ the opportunity to fight alongside Caesar and share in his victories.

    Also Vercingetorix was capable of his own victories:
    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gergovia


  • Anyone know of any medieval age generals we can compare?


  • William the Conqueror vs. Joan of Arc?


  • Let us not forget that those “leaderless nekkid Celts” and the Scotts and the Welsh also soundly HALTED the Roman advances on multiple occasions.


  • And let’s not forget I’m speaking about the Gauls that Ceaser dealt with.

    And agian let me say that my “naked” comment was a weak response to the weak “levies” remark leveled at Alexander’s victory against Darius’s army at Gaugamela. I fully realize that were not……not …not… all naked, every one of them, always, everytime they went into battle.

    Based on what I’ve read, so far, the indication is, in general, that the Gaul were not well lead  and they were difficult to organize, which leads trouble when fighting Rome in large battles. And this was the case during Caesar campaigns. However, this does not diminish Caesar’s accomplishments as I tried to make clear in my last post.

    i dont think you can dismiss both Vercingetorix and Commius

    I don’t belive I really was. I knew nothing, really, of Vercingetorix before this thread. And I don’t know Commius, either.

    I doubt that Caesar would allow some ‘naked savage’ the opportunity to fight alongside Caesar and share in his victories.

    I think anyone would be uncomfortable with a naked barbarian standing beside you. :mrgreen:

    Chieftains would have been able to afford proper armor and quality weapons. They probably would not have been naked, unless they were trying to be particularly heroic or they we just that" hardcore"


  • @Imperious:

    William the Conqueror vs. Joan of Arc?

    We can compare the two generals at the Battle of Hastings.  William the Conqueror vs. Harold II.


  • General Kitty says lets revive this thread!

    [attachment deleted by admin]


  • That looks like a Romulan commander!


  • @Imperious:

    That looks like a Romulan commander!

    lol  His name is Whiskerus Maximus!!  :lol:


  • It takes a pretty drunk person to be able to do that to a cat.

    Of course we know what they were drinking from the pic… margaritas!


  • @MechanizedWarfare:

    General Kitty says lets revive this thread!

    is there napoleon,ceaser of the sea?


  • I just watched amok time which is an old star trek episode and that cat looks more like a vulcan. Same hat same face.

  • '19 Moderator

    @Imperious:

    Bratwurst vs. sausage

    This is a completely unfair comparison.  Bratwurst is the king of the sausages.


  • @dezrtfish:

    @Imperious:

    Bratwurst vs. sausage

    This is a completely unfair comparison.  Bratwurst is the king of the sausages.

    [attachment deleted by admin]


  • Reviving this old thread……heres an interesting video on Hannibal’s victory at the Battle of Cannae, the biggest bloodiest battle of the ancient world.

    http://youtube.com/watch?v=BqauRxDiMpU


  • Ceaser of course. Ceaser would have whooped up on Alexander any day.

  • 2007 AAR League

    i still disagree.  alexander had him.


  • Another old poll worthy of discussion.

    I vote for Julius Caesar.

Suggested Topics

  • 2
  • 1
  • 2
  • 8
  • 9
  • 7
  • 6
  • 1
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

42

Online

17.6k

Users

40.1k

Topics

1.7m

Posts