• Okay then I was just confused.  I know back when they were talking about balancing Pacific I saw somewhere to get Japan to not do a J1 they were offered a 10pt a turn National Objective.  Maybe it was just someones suggestion I saw and not offical set up by Larry Harris.  My friend mentioned it to me last night and I told him I was not sure.


  • @Frank:

    Okay then I was just confused.  I know back when they were talking about balancing Pacific I saw somewhere to get Japan to not do a J1 they were offered a 10pt a turn National Objective.  Maybe it was just someones suggestion I saw and not offical set up by Larry Harris.  My friend mentioned it to me last night and I told him I was not sure.

    Yeah, that was in the works, but is not currently part of alpha. it may be added if alpha swings the game to the allies too much


  • @calvinhobbesliker:

    @gamerman01:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    But that naval base, for some reason, can repair US ships but not UK ships

    That can’t be right.  Why are you saying that?  Of course it can still repair UK ships.  Who, or what page of what rulebook or FAQ said they can’t?

    Well, UK skips it purchase and repair phase if London has fallen, so it can’t repair ships. i think Krieg has confirmed this somewhere.

    OK, but in that case it can’t repair US ships either, so that would at least be consistent.


  • @gamerman01:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    @gamerman01:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    But that naval base, for some reason, can repair US ships but not UK ships

    That can’t be right.  Why are you saying that?  Of course it can still repair UK ships.  Who, or what page of what rulebook or FAQ said they can’t?

    Well, UK skips it purchase and repair phase if London has fallen, so it can’t repair ships. i think Krieg has confirmed this somewhere.

    OK, but in that case it can’t repair US ships either, so that would at least be consistent.

    US ships repair in US’s purchase/repair phase, which it still has.


  • @calvinhobbesliker:

    US ships repair in US’s purchase/repair phase, which it still has.

    Oh - I see I’ve been playing this wrong, after reviewing the rule on page 12.

    I thought a power repaired their own ships and allied ships at their naval bases on their turn, but that is not the case.

    A power repairs all their own ships that are at their own operative naval bases or at the operative (no more than 2 damage) naval bases of their allies.  So a power NEVER repairs other powers’ ships on their turn.  (e.g. USA can only repair USA ships on USA’s turn, not any of it’s ally’s.  UK ship off of EUS would not be repaired until UK turn)

    Big difference.  I’m glad this came up - thanks, Calvin.


  • @gamerman01:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    US ships repair in US’s purchase/repair phase, which it still has.

    Oh - I see I’ve been playing this wrong, after reviewing the rule on page 12.

    I thought a power repaired their own ships and allied ships at their naval bases on their turn, but that is not the case.

    A power repairs all their own ships that are at their own operative naval bases or at the operative (no more than 2 damage) naval bases of their allies.  So a power NEVER repairs other powers’ ships on their turn.  (e.g. USA can only repair USA ships on USA’s turn, not any of it’s ally’s.  UK ship off of EUS would not be repaired until UK turn)

    Big difference.  I’m glad this came up - thanks, Calvin.

    You’re welcome


  • Which of the following are actual sea zones like the Caspian Sea:
    Great Lakes(if they are counted, are they 1 sea zone or many)
    Lake Victoria
    Lake Biyakal
    Lake Ladoga(so Russia can build in it)


  • @calvinhobbesliker:

    Which of the following are actual sea zones like the Caspian Sea:
    Great Lakes(if they are counted, are they 1 sea zone or many)
    Lake Victoria
    Lake Biyakal
    Lake Ladoga(so Russia can build in it)

    Calvin, I’m sure the latter 3 are not sea zones, because they don’t add any extra movement possibility (the territories border each other anyway, unlike with the Caspian now).

    However, I think you have a good question with the Great Lakes.  Can the USA build out of Chicago (CUS) and sail ships up the river to the Atlantic?  And can Canada build into the Great Lakes and later sail to the Atlantic (when there is an eminent threat from the East)?  I doubt it, but that would be cool if you could.

    Waiting for Krieghund……


  • Well, Ladoga allows Russia to build a fleet there and bombard from it.

    If the Great Lakes were sea zones, I doubt you could sail up the St. Lawrence River


  • @calvinhobbesliker:

    Well, Ladoga allows Russia to build a fleet there and bombard from it.

    If the Great Lakes were sea zones, I doubt you could sail up the St. Lawrence River

    Although that is how the French took over Quebec and subsequently CUS


  • @calvinhobbesliker:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    Well, Ladoga allows Russia to build a fleet there and bombard from it.

    If the Great Lakes were sea zones, I doubt you could sail up the St. Lawrence River

    Although that is how the French took over Quebec and subsequently CUS

    Yes, but is it big enough for WWII warships?  I wouldn’t know.


  • @calvinhobbesliker:

    Well, Ladoga allows Russia to build a fleet there and bombard from it.

    If the Great Lakes were sea zones, I doubt you could sail up the St. Lawrence River

    Calvin, be serious.  There is no flippin’ way the Russians could ever think about building a cruiser or battleship in Ladoga.  :lol:


  • @gamerman01:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    Well, Ladoga allows Russia to build a fleet there and bombard from it.

    If the Great Lakes were sea zones, I doubt you could sail up the St. Lawrence River

    Calvin, be serious.  There is no flippin’ way the Russians could ever think about building a cruiser or battleship in Ladoga.  :lol:

    Sort of like how US would never build a fleet in great Lakes instead of Z101


  • @calvinhobbesliker:

    @gamerman01:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    Well, Ladoga allows Russia to build a fleet there and bombard from it.

    If the Great Lakes were sea zones, I doubt you could sail up the St. Lawrence River

    Calvin, be serious.  There is no flippin’ way the Russians could ever think about building a cruiser or battleship in Ladoga.  :lol:

    Sort of like how US would never build a fleet in great Lakes instead of Z101

    No, you’re wrong.  When Axis has a big fleet in Z91, Z101 is in great danger.  There may very well be times when the US would want to build in the Great Lakes.  So don’t try to turn my criticism back on myself, because it’s a totally different situation.

  • Official Q&A

    The Caspian Sea is the only unnumbered sea zone.  All other unnumbered water areas are not sea zones, and are not game spaces.


  • @gamerman01:

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    How does one forget Rome if it’s building 10 inf a turn?

    Pretty sure he meant Germany wanted to BYPASS taking Rome over because of the 10 build per turn.

    GrandMaster, Calvin is correct.  When a capital falls (Rome), its allies (Germany and Japan) are unable to take control of any of those (Italian) territories.  However, if an enemy takes control of Italian territory, then Germany and Japan would be able to take control by taking those territories out of Allied hands.

    It’s the same reason the Allies can’t take control of French territory after Paris falls on turn 1.  As soon as an Axis power takes a French territory, however, it is then available for any Ally to take it over and control it.  Same rules.

    Thanks for the help. We went with this this is in the game as well. It just seemed like a silly rule in this particular situation. Nearly all of Africa’s income dissappeared even though German troops could easily stand in those territories undisputed.


  • Does Ontario border EUS? Does Alberta border CUS? Does New Brunswick border Quebec?

  • Official Q&A

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    Does Ontario border EUS?

    Yes.

    @calvinhobbesliker:

    Does Alberta border CUS? Does New Brunswick border Quebec?

    Probably.  I don’t have final confirmation yet, though.

  • 2007 AAR League

    Is their a PDF version of the rules to download?


  • @Emperor:

    Is their a PDF version of the rules to download?

    Remember that you always have to wait a few months after release.

    BTW, I think you have at least 2 AA50 games to get to(with bold and gamer)

Suggested Topics

Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

35

Online

17.3k

Users

39.9k

Topics

1.7m

Posts