Yes, I have tried. It doesn’t work. With only 1 IPC, you can’t produce enough units to get your money’s worth out of it.
Does Germany ever build ICs?
-
Well, I, for one, have used the Western Europe Industrial Complex manuever quite well. It forces England to Turtle instead of trying to counter your Atlantic Fleet leaving the allies at the mercy of Germany. (this is especially good with the NA giving Germany a free submarine per round.)
The bummer is that you have to pull out of Eastern Europe to consolidate your forces before pushing back in. That gives Russia a lot of starting capital to operate with. So don’t do this unless you know you are superior to your opponent.
BTW, this is about the only case I will actually blow the 16 IPCs for a carrier in the Baltic Sea. I really see this as a waste of cash. It gives you almost no offensive abilities and only protects ships you don’t really NEED to win the game. Besides, 16 IPC is 4 Artillery Pieces or 3X the offensive punch against Russia in units. (+4 on your infantry and +8 for the units themselves, that’s 12 attack (roughly 2 hits) vs 4 attack (maybe a hit))
-
Actually Jen, it’s 4X the offensive punch (or 3X more punch). 4 art @ 2 + 4 inf @ 2 = 16 vs. 4 inf @ 1 = 4 16 vs. 4 = 4X.
-
Once the IC is present though, it does give you the option to deliver units instantly, which might be critical in some circumstances.
I don’t know, I just hate those Inf. taking so long to get to the front. I guess TRNs are another option.
-
Crazy Straw’s analysis shows that it doesn’t really take that long for the inf to get to the front. Yes on the second turn you would have 3 inf in UKR with the IC and none without the IC, but on the third turn you would have 6 inf in UKR either way.
-
Actually Jen, it’s 4X the offensive punch (or 3X more punch). 4 art @ 2 + 4 inf @ 2 = 16 vs. 4 inf @ 1 = 4 16 vs. 4 = 4X.
That’s what I was trying to say. My words just got garbled in my mind, sorry. Hey, I’m a math major, not an English major!!!
-
Okay, but you are all assuming Germany has Ukraine on R1 for some reason. (Can’t build an IC in newly captured territory.)
Also, why wouldn’t the 5 infantry be better? Eh?
At least with transports you have the option of hitting England if she’s lightly defended for a quick buck.
-
how about if the uk/us captures france. beacuse it takes one turn to buld a factory you should be able to hold france for the rest of the game.
-
how about if the uk/us captures france. beacuse it takes one turn to buld a factory you should be able to hold france for the rest of the game.
Moving off topic there; the question is about a GERMAN built IC.
-
Western… MAYBE… IF you are doing a Naval Dominance strat with Germany and think you can pull it off (high enough bid in Africa that you can get the 10-11 IPC’s transfered from UK to Germany to have Germany only at a 10 IPC disadvantage to the UK/USA combo, and that Japan can move fast enough to tie up Russia completely.
Otherwise, no way; except perhaps late game if you want to just “rub it in” and you build a German IC in Eastern Canada :-D
-
I’ve seen a German in E. Canada before. Of course, this was a game to the death and England/Russia had already fallen and Germany was just putting teh coup de tat on America.