What to do with my German Navy?

I like to buy an AC & 1 Trn for the baltic on G1.  I find the extra transport to be really useful.  Not only does the UK have to seriously think about a strike on the home land, but any landings in Norway can be easily countered on G2 with the ability to bring 4 ground units plus air support.  Has anyone else used this strategy?  with or without success?

I would be leary of it, simply because the 16 IPC for an AC drops you to an 8 INF buy for G1.  Adding a TRN to that drops you to only 16 IPC’s of land units.  And against a good Russian player, that could be fatal.  Drawing more troops off to re-take Norway on top of the reduced G1 buy… sounds SERIOUSLY fatal against a strong Russian player.

Switch-

Granted the strategy has some risk to it (such is the nature of war) but I disagree that it is “Seriously Fatal”, Russia can’t pose a real threat until at least turn 3, by then germany’s defenses will be in place.  Next free game you have let me know and we’ll put it to the test  :wink:

The problem STARTS earlier than that…

Germany needs INCOME.  They will lose West Russia and either Bel or Ukraine on R1.  They will lose Norway on UK1 (Germany may be able to re-take it in G2, but that means postponing Karelia).  US lands in Algeria on US 1 or2.

R2 and R3 are the problems.

With only 16 IPC of land unit build on G1, Germany has nothing to move toward the Russian Front on G2.  That means that basically Germany has to stop Russia with only their remaining starting forces, and Russia has outbuilt them nearly 2-1 for this round of battle.

By the time Germany has built, and begun staging forward new units, they don;t have to stage very far.  Eastern and Balkans are now being traded instead of Ukraine.  THAT leaves Germany building not only pitiful numbers of ground troops on G1 due to the naval build, but fewer units in each subsequent round due to lost income.

And with forces being spent on Norway and in Africa, Germany is actually NEGATIVE net units on G2 against Russia.

It is an income shift of about 6 IPC’s.  6 less for Germany, 6 more for Russia.  That makes them nearly even at around 30ish IPC’s each (Germany around the mid 30’s until they are booted out of Africa), and that is before UK and US are figured in to the equation.

You may be right but…you haven’t convinced me.  :-P

Germany needs INCOME.  They will lose West Russia and either Bel or Ukraine on R1.  They will lose Norway on UK1 (Germany may be able to re-take it in G2, but that means postponing Karelia).  US lands in Algeria on US 1 or2.

W. Russia is lost, but Bel or Ukraine can be retaken along with karelia and egypt on G1 (net gain of 2 IPC) giving germany 42 IPC to spend on G2 vs 29 IPC at best for russia on round 2.

With only 16 IPC of land unit build on G1, Germany has nothing to move toward the Russian Front on G2.  That means that basically Germany has to stop Russia with only their remaining starting forces, and Russia has outbuilt them nearly 2-1 for this round of battle.

Russia’s round 1 build is only 24 IPC, a German build of 16 (8 IPC difference) plus starting forces is sufficient to hold the line for one round.  It also assumes Russia’s entire build is directed towards germany with nothing allocated to the east.

Meanwhile with the extra baltic transport the northern flank becomes less of a problem.

I think it’s a workable strategy (I’ve certainly had good results from it).  I invite you to prove me wrong.   :roll:  Â

If I were not already booked out 3 games ahead, I would take you up on it :-)

But once you counter in Ukraine/Bel and take Karelia in G2, that is it.  Eastern is basically bare, Balkans IS bare.  Karelia is thin, Norway if you re-took it is TRANSPARENT, and your Ukraine and Bel forces are sitting next to the West Russia Stack… probably 7 INF, 2 ART, 4 ARM… and 2 FIG in reserve in Caucuses or Russia.  THAT force will decimate Germany’s forces on the front in Bel/Ukraine, and UK can handle Norway/Karelia.  Meanwhile, the US just landed in Algeria.

What are you going to counter Russia with on G3 in Bel, West Russia and Ukraine?  The 16 IPC’s worth of units you bought in G1 that you moved to Eastern?  That and your FIGs?  Good bye luftwaffe.

If you only buy 5 land units in G1, you only have 5 land units to move east in G2 (and none to move to Western).  And of those 5 units, you want to be able to TRN 4 of them to argue Norway with UK?  And 2 more to re-take Egypt after UK counters from India?  That is a NEGATIVE NET BUILD for Germany in Europe.  Added to R1 losses…

Sorry, that just doesn;t work.  Try that strat and Russia WILL be in Eastern IN FORCE on R3 (if they want to), and Western WILL fall to the Allies for the first time in UK3.  Africa will never result in gains for Germany, and will never equal losses in central Europe.  You just do not have enough intial forces.

If you want specifics, I’ll post them.

Here they are…
Assume and R1 of Ukraine and West Russia, both were “average”… both fell to Russia.

At the start of G1, Germany has 7 INF in Central Europe, 3 in Northern, 2 in Southern and 2 in Western, plus 3 in Germany.  They have 7 ARM left in all of Europe, 5 FIGs, a BOM, and 1 ART (not counting Africa troops).

Germany HAS to re-take Ukraine… not an option.  You said you also want Karelia.  And you go after Egypt.

The Karelia move pulls 2 German INF to Karelia, plus the 3 Norway forces (if you want to have more than token resistance against the UK attack in UK1).  Egypt requires 2 units (1 INF, 1 ART) from Southern to leave Europe for Africa.  You are also going to be sending at least 1 FIG and your BOM down there if you want to TAKE it, and have a chance at re-taking it in G2.  Against Ukraine you use minimal force to take… Let’s say 3 INF and 1 ARM, and you take it with 2 INF and 1 ARM.  And lets assume you stage your ARM in Eastern (or perhaps you advance stage to Karelia, so shift those forces that could reach…  You protect your Western FIGs with an INF from Germany and 1 from Southern.  You consolidate the rest of your forces from Central Europe to Eastern, and you “picket” Belorussia with 1 INF.

For build placement, you need to put 2 units in Southern for transport to Africa to re-take Egypt in G2… 1 INF, 1 ART to give you offensive punch.  That leaves 3 INF Germany.

Here is your forces summary after G1 with average dice…
Europe:
Western:  4 INF, 3 FIG, 1 AA
Southern:  1 INF, 1 ART, 1 AA, 1 IC
Germany:  3 INF, 1 AA, 1 IC
Balkans:  vacant
Ukraine:  2 INF, 1 ARM
Belorussia:  1 INF
Karelia:  9 INF, 3 ARM
Eastern:  3 ARM
Norway:  vacant.

Africa:
Libya:  1 INF, 1 ART, 1 FIG, 1 BOM
Egypt:  1 ARM, 1 ART

Naval:
SZ15:  1 BB, 1 TRN
SZ5:  2 SUB, 2 TRN, 1 DST, 1 AC, 1 FIG

That is with creating a “Karelia Stack”.  You could shift some of thsoe units to Eastern if you like.

Here is the Russian forces you face in R2:
West Russia Stack:  6 INF, 2 ART, 1 ARM
Caucuses:  5 INF, 1 ARM, 2 FIG
Archangel:  1 INF
Russia:  2 ARM

That is almost DEAD even, INF for INF, ARM for ARM in central Europe.  But Germany will ONLY have 3 replacement units to send east on G2.  Russia has 8 from R1, 8 more coming in R2.

And dead even is fine… IF UK were not going to drop 6 divisions backed up by 3 AF units on UK2, and if the US was not going to able to start landing 4 units plus AF in US2.

Pencil me in for game 4.  :-D

Don’t be so stodgy, your analysis is fine based on what you would do, but you can’t predict what I’ll do, the great thing about this game is it’s unpredictability.  After round 1 who knows what the board will look like.  In any case under your scenario you’d be throwing everything at Germany (they could never withstand that no matter what they bought) meanwhile Japan will be knocking at russia’s back door.  :lol:

Everything except 6 INF from Russia, 4 INF and a FIG from the US, plus any assorted AF flown in , IC’s built, etc.

And Japan can;t get that much onto the contient in a couple of rounds… they only have 1 TRN on J1…

OK, pencilled in for a future game.  We’ll go ahead and set it with you as Axis now so you can test your German uber-navy :-)

LOL…your on.  :mrgreen: (just wanted to use this Icon, I haven’t seen hair like that since i was in high school!)

I think a better investment is to buy an AC for the mediteranean fleet. :-P

I’ve played a few games where i’ve purchased a 2nd carrier for the med, but haven’t ever put one there on G1.  What do you do about your baltic fleet?

I find it critical to build an AC in the Med If you are playing a KGF. Landlocked Germany is no good. The baltic fleet is cannon fodder to attack allied ships with your planes. I usually defend that as well by buying a destroyer… just to try things out.

I usually operate under the theory that any Navy for Germany except for the Baltic AC and a few Baltic transports is money out the window. As the Allies my second axiom is “Sink the German Navy as soon as practical.”

“Sink the German Navy as soon as practical.”

Right you are!

What´s your first axiom?

@xenon:

“Sink the German Navy as soon as practical.”

Right you are!

What´s your first axiom?

It’s probably take out his capital as quick as you can! :-P :-D

Take out the capital as soon as you can is my goal.  My axioms are things I try to keep in my mind to acheive my goal.

1st Axiom  “When in doubt as to what to buy, buy INF.”

2nd Axiom “Sink any naval units you can as soon as practical and that is still to slow.”

3rd Axiom “See that your naval units don’t meet Davy Jones alone.”

4th Axiom “All other axioms are useless if you don’t defend your capital.”

5th Axiom "Stay on target. Pick a goal and stick to it.

6th Axiom “Be more concerned with the sure paths to defeat than the uncertain paths to victory.”

D. Fox might wish to take No 4 to heart.  :evil:

I would be curious to hear any axioms that any one else has. I would also be curious to any thoughts on my axioms.

My axioms are:

1st Axiom  Don’t do something stupid.

2nd Axiom If you did something stupid, don’t do it again.

3rd Axiom If you’re still doing the same stupid thing…STOP!!!

4th Axiom If you can’t stop doing the same stupid thing, lock your game up in the closet.

:roll:

When you are pulling all of your forces out of your capital to move them somewhere, and you are ABSOLUTELY SURE that no enemy units can reach…  and you have triple checked and NOTHING can reach…

Leave a couple of INF behind… just in case you missed something :-)

(I lost a game of Classic that way once…)

jsp4563 that is an excellent set and I will be adopting number one as one of my own axioms. Perhaps this should have its own thread?