How would you change the map?


  • Actually the neutrals are useful now in AARHE as you can attack them.
    So in many situations you could make an easier amphibious landing if area is particularly fortifieid.

    Man we got all kinds of people joining in here!

    Yes Imperious Leader considers you to be a contributor to the AARHE project.  :-)


  • all islands should be worth something to encourage U.S. pacific activity

    russia should have 0 IPC value territories in siberia to discourage jap tanks in the tundra

    there should be a burma territory between india and frindo to allow a viable indian uk complex

    middle east should be more valuable (oil resources) to encourage activity on this front

    adopt the pacific/europe sub policy (no air only attacks) to encourage u-boats

    victory city conditions should require HOLDING them for an entire round not just a “quickie” capture

    atlantic islands?

    cruisers (3/3) and destroyers (2/2)?

    more possibilities pending


  • Subs ionly against air only SHOULD have the opportunity to retreat and/or hide.

    AF should ahve to roll a “to hit” to even DETECT the sub they are flying over, then the sub would have a defensive roll to submerge and excape before the FIG ever fired.  If the FIG sees the SUB, and teh sub fails their evasion, then combat as normal (FIG rolls to hit, then sub submerges)

    Rule would only apply to SUBs w/o any other ships present in the same sea zone.


  • about Pacific war,
    an income adjustment is a bit of a hack really

    the reason why we don’t have Pacific war is due to underlying problems like combat rules
    only Solomon Islands should be given 1 IPC

    Solomon Islands 28,450km^2
    Okinawa 2,271.30 km^2
    Malta 316km^2
    Gibraltar 6.5km^2
    Wake Island 6.5km^2
    Midway ~5km^2
    Caroline Island 3.76km^2


  • Caroline Islands are a chain of islands

    Also the value of the land as a strategic base presents its economic value because if they fell it would entail loss of vital areas to bring resources to that nation. Thats not possible to account for in another manner so its done this way by adding some token value so it will be fought over and in a small way players will ‘see’ some imporatance with these locations.


  • yeah that figure was probably only for the main island in Caroline Islands

    don’t worry I was just replying to critmonster post

    from previous discussion you already know how I feel and I already know how to feel
    I am fine with the phase 3 map (Caroline and Solomons get 1 IPC each) compromise rather than giving Wake and Midway income too


  • great


  • tek, thanks for replying, but i’m not sure what the point of posting land mass was.  then i read leader’s post and it stated my point nicely, thanks :-)

    switch, i think giving subs a “shot” when air only hits to submerge before attack would be reasonable.


  • The only problem I really have is how out of shape the map is.  I’d like To have a realistic looking game board (probably requiring a larger board) instead of this big ugly hunk of land trying to represent europe.  I saw a picture on boardgamegeek under revised that showed some guys map with a realistic looking world (only the eastern front was shown), I really liked it.


  • Yeah I recall seeing some photos somewhere on the internet.

    Someone traced a real map.
    Painted it on a huge piece of wood. A0 or A-1.  :mrgreen:

Suggested Topics

  • 14
  • 11
  • 1
  • 1
  • 1
  • 10
  • 7
  • 5
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

88

Online

17.3k

Users

39.8k

Topics

1.7m

Posts