I hope this one is as fun as the last one.
Vance (Allies) vs. AlexGreat (Axis), G40 Alpha +3
-
3. NON-COMBAT MOVES
Bomber Algeria –> Alexandria
Fighter Tobruk --> Alexandria
Fighter S-Italy --> Alexandria
1 Inf Albania --> Yugo
Arm, Art S-France --> N-Italy4. MOBILIZE
1 TT SZ 97
1 Art, 3 INF N-Italy5. INCOME
20 (terr) + 17 (NO) = 37
-
Italy is rich!
ANZAC 2
PURCHASE & REPAIR
1 transport
1 inf
1 art
14 totalCOMBAT MOVES
noneNONCOMBAT MOVES
z39
2 fig from QueenslandSouth Australia
2 inf from New South WalesMOBILIZE UNITS
1 inf, 1 art in new South Wales
1 transport in z62COLLECT INCOME
ANZAC 2 = 10(territories) +5(malaya)FRANCE
COMBAT MOVES
Transjordan (walk in)
1 inf from SyriaNONCOMBAT MOVES
z39
1 destroyer from z77French Equatorial Africa
1 inf from French Central AfricaEireland
1 inf from Scotland -
**** If you did read my request for Japan and not replying means not agreeing, no probs, my mistake, technically. If you did not read, pls have a look***
Germany 3
1. PURCHASE
- 2 TT (14)
- 9 Inf (27)
- 3 Mech (12)
2. COMBAT MOVES
Air Base UK <– 1 Tac Holland; Escort: 1 Fighter SZ 112
UK <-- 6 Arm, 7 Art, 13 Inf, 2 Bomber, 4 Fighter, 4 Tac3. COMBAT
3.1. Strategic Bombing Raid Air Base UK (on the assumption that this will be played out before Amphibious Assaults and general combat, as this sequence is laid down in the rules, ie 3 damage to an airbase in this phase will preclude scrambling later on during the amphibious assault phase). Also on the assumption that fighters who intercepted cannot participate in the battle for the UK or scramble, independently of any damage or not to the airbase.
Pls correct me if I got the rules wrong, and if not, pls orders for interception!
-
Transports via SZ 110
-
Sorry I didn’t read your question about the IC. Yes go ahead and move it to manchuria.
Now the bad news. All battles in a turn are considered to take place simultaneously. So you can’t bomb the airbase to stop the scramble (and you really don’t want to bomb the airbase that you will own when you take London LOL). So do you want to re-do your move?
-
I will scramble 3 fighters from against your fleet in z110, so if you want maybe you can use the planes you were going to use against the airbase to cover your fleet? Up to you.
-
Ok Vance, just wanted to be convinced because the rules in the rulebook clearly say “Combat sequence: 1. Strat Bombing raid, 2. Amphibious aussaults, 3. General combat”.
The word sequence implies to me that it is step by step, I did not read “simultaneously” or something like that anywhere. I know that all attacks need to be declared simultaneously, of course.Its really to my best knowldedge that I cant find anything contrary to my interpretation of the rules, and I also dont find a passage that would explicitly say that a facility disabled still works in the same turn, just that “capabilities are decreased or eliminated” (is there a Q&A somewhere, or a Krieghund explanation for future reference in my local group?), but I never had a situation where it was relevant, and you surely have way more experience than me, so of course I wont contest your explanation. So yes, I need to find another way.
As for the bombing the air base, yes, I’d very much want that as I would not commit my warships to this attack….sacrificing the transports is bad enough courtesy to your combined air force :-), building infrastructure to better protect my warships from the 6 US bombers and then the British wave is even worse, however, because I will still bleed, even if it will cost you the 6 bombers and a few British air (provided my own air survives UK battle).
-
OK I am pretty certain that you can;t bomb the airbase to prevent scramble on the same turn, but I’ll make a compromise with you because you planned out your move assuming that you could. So what I will do is NOT scramble. You can go ahead with your attack as planned.
In the meantime I will look around on the harris site and see if Krieghund has said anything about this somewhere.
-
I really would like to do it as it is meant to be in the rules, and as you set up the situation very well in my opinion, you should reap the rewards (I am not experienced in the way of sea lion, surely it can be done better, but the way you arranged your forces makes me doubt if sea-lion is the way to go for the Axis….especially since the die were quite in my favor in Europe, so far).
I need an hour or so anyway for the kid, maybe you find something definite until then. Only something that would support my view will make me do what I wrote below, every other result including none I will re-think my moves.
-
Ah ha! I found the answer.
In the alpha +3 rules on the Harris site, the section on scramble says: “Scrambling is a special movement that the defender can make at the end of the Combat Move phase. It must be done after all of the attacker�s combat movements have been completed and all attacks have been declared.”
In the rule book, Strategic bombing raids occur at the beginning of the Conduct Combat phase.
Combat Movement comes before Conduct Combat. So my planes would be over z110 before your bombers hit my airbase!
For future reference, a good way to knock out that airbase before sea lion is to attack it with the Italian bomber on I2.
In any case, I didn’t scramble. So go ahead and if you want to you can call off bombing the airbase (no point damaging your own airbase LOL)
Good question Alex!
-
thats settled, then, thx for taking the time.
I am happy to concede the game as price for my failure to set this up more properly, but still would like to continue (with you not scrambling against my unprotected transports, just like as if the Italian bomber would have been more thorough). I learned so much already, would not want to forego the next lessons :-D
-
Don’t be silly. The game is not even close to being won or lost by either side!
-
dont get me wrong, I hate losing, but I am not the bookies favorite right now, and you did offer a major concession already
Doesnt mean that I stop trying everything I can here. :-)
Germany should be up soon.
-
Redo Germany 3
1. PURCHASE
- 1 TT (7)
- 14 Inf (42)
- 1 Mech (4)
2. COMBAT MOVES
UK <– 6 Arm, 7 Art, 13 Inf, 2 Bomber, 5 Fighter, 5 Tac via 13 TTs SZ 113 --> 110
AA Guns
Rolls: 9@1; Total Hits: 09@1: (5, 2, 6, 4, 2, 6, 4, 2, 6) -
UK Battle, Rd 1
A
Rolls: 7@4 11@3 14@2 6@1; Total Hits: 187@4: (4, 5, 3, 5, 1, 4, 2)11@3: (2, 2, 3, 6, 1, 2, 4, 6, 6, 1, 6)14@2: (6, 2, 6, 5, 6, 4, 5, 4, 2, 1, 2, 2, 2, 6)6@1: (6, 5, 5, 1, 2, 6)
D
:aaa 16@2 3@4 -
forgot syntax
D
Rolls: 16@2 3@4; Total Hits: 916@2: (2, 4, 3, 2, 5, 2, 4, 6, 4, 4, 2, 1, 1, 2, 1, 5)3@4: (1, 5, 5) -
UK, Rd 2
A
Rolls: 7@4 11@3 11@2; Total Hits: 157@4: (3, 4, 1, 6, 1, 3, 6)11@3: (1, 2, 6, 2, 1, 4, 5, 2, 2, 5, 5)11@2: (4, 1, 4, 2, 4, 3, 6, 2, 1, 3, 3)
D
Rolls: 3@4 1@2; Total Hits: 23@4: (3, 1, 6)1@2: (6) -
3. NON-COMBAT MOVES
1 Inf Greece –> TT SZ 92
1 Inf Greece --> Bulgaria
3 Arm Greece --> Yugo
2 Bomb UK --> W-Germany
5 TAC, 5 Fight UK --> Holland
2 Subs SZ 108 --> SZ 110
1 Sub SZ 110 --> SZ 125
1 Sub SZ 110 --> SZ 113
CR, BB, AC SZ 112 --> SZ 113
2 Mech Holland --> Germany
5 Inf, Art S-Germany --> Germany4. MOBILIZE
TT SZ 113 (W-Germany)
10 Inf Germany
1 Mech, 1 Inf W-Germany
3 Inf France5. INCOME
49 (terr) + 10 (NO) + 28 (UK Treasury) = 87
-
Nice idea to try and hide your fleet inside the Danish strait!
USSR 3
-
-
- Soviet Union Declares War on Germany
-
and Italy * * *
PURCHASE & REPAIR
1 transport
1 inf
1 art
6 mech
38 totalCOMBAT MOVES
z113
1 sub, 1 cruiser, 1 battleship, 1 carrier, 1 transport
1 sub from z115
1 cruiser from z114My sub is doing a first strike.
As your first strike, you can submerge your sub or let shoot back @1. Submerge orders?Poland (1 inf)
11 inf, 1 art from Baltic states
aRolls: 3@1, 2@2; Total Hits: 13@1,: (6, 6, 3)2@2: (2, 6)
dRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (6)Hungary (1 inf)
4 inf, 1 art from East Poland
aRolls: 3@1, 2@2; Total Hits: 13@1,: (5, 3, 5)2@2: (1, 5)
dRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 01@2: (5)Romania (1 inf)
4 inf from East Poland
1 art Bessarabia
aRolls: 3@1, 2@2; Total Hits: 13@1,: (1, 4, 3)2@2: (4, 5)
dRolls: 1@2; Total Hits: 11@2: (2) -
-
Sub stays
Suggested Topics
