Well, I supose good leadership could be a matter of luck, Patton wasn’t killed in WWI, lucky for us. Also it’s not always clear who will be a great leader, sometimes a captain or even some nameless grunt can change a battle. The point is if battles always went the way they should this game would be boring, I love the lopsided battles, when they are for me or against me. They make the game more interesting and fun.
Here’s another one, same game.
Germany invades Caucuses with 6 Ftrs, 3 Arm and 4Inf against 4Inf and 1Ftr
Opening round Russia rolls a yatzee - 5 aces for AA and then hits with all 4 Inf
in the end Germany retreated its last fighter and 1 Arm leaving 1 Inf holding Stalingrad, I guess Zukov was there…