My Piece Compartments Solution

Nice job. You could probably sell those.

You use a radial arm saw to cut foam board??  What kind of blade are you using?  Although I haven’t tried it, I can only imagine the mess my rough-cut blade would make of the foam board!  There wouldn’t be anything left!

I have been using a utility knife to cut my foam board, but it is a major pain in the a$$.  If a power saw really worked, and left a nice edge, I would do that in a heartbeat!

@Xayd74:

@Brain:

Do you still have all of your fingers?

It’s easy to get complacent using any tool when mired in many cuts. But a radial arm saw can send a 2x4 through a wall. One must exercise caution when using any tool that operates on a track.

Yes, all power tools are dangerous. I used to watch Tim Allen on Tool Time. :-D

That’s a nice job.

In the end though, since I’m stripping my A&A 1942 Ed. for extra pieces anyways and I need more room, I went with 5 plastic “bead sorting boxes” from Michaels (craft store) at $2.99 apiece.  The only modification they required was that 3 of the 25 compartments have walls removed via exacto knife so that they fit my infantry, carriers, and battleships.

I figure I’ll pick up four more when they have a sale and we’re close to the Europe A&A 1940 release and I can get between 25% and 40% off.

@GDFTigerTank:

I went with 5 plastic “bead sorting boxes” from Michaels (craft store) at $2.99 apiece.  The only modification they required was that 3 of the 25 compartments have walls removed via exacto knife so that they fit my infantry, carriers, and battleships.

How about some pictures?

@Brain:

How about some pictures?

Why certainly!

A picture of -from left to right- my Axis AA Gun, Allied AA Gun, Major IC, and Minor IC.  You’ll see that the Minor IC has had the 2nd smokestack lopped off at an angle to match the contour of the roof, and then been painted to match the rest of the building and roof.  Came out quite well I think.

Major IC has fire engine red sides, a black roof, and silver stacks.  Minor IC has dark red “wine” colored sides, brown roof, and black stack.

Another picture of my currently painted pieces.

This is my standard box.  The only compartments that were modified in each were the infantry, battleships, and carriers which were doubled in size by removing 1 adjacent compartment partition.

This is my China & General Box, which you can see is modified slightly differently to accommodate my Major and Minor ICs.  I’ll also have room for the custom Naval Base and Airfield tokens arriving from LITKO soon.

Here’s all my boxes filled and stacked.  Boy I have a lot of painting to do!

This is the brand and only packaging (other than clear plastic) for the boxes I bought so you can find the exact ones I got.  Again, I got them from Michaels, they were $2.99 apiece.

Those boxes look perfect for A&A, Thank you for the pictures

WRT the original poster: Your solution reminds me of the original white foam boxes that came with the old A&A (2nd Edition it is? Not sure)

It’s the first A&A game my playgroup used, after which we jumped to Revised (no boxes at all), onwards to AA50 (yes, boxes!..but with only 3 huge compartments) and now AAP40 (yes, boxes!..no dividers at all…).
It’s amazing to see that the original AA, fabricated and published in what, the 80’s? …had the best boxes of all versions, and that how the game evolves, such attributes get lesser and lesser in quality and usability. (You’d think that the test playgroup would notice such annoying things aswell?)

Anyhew…I went with the boardgamegeek solution yesterday, and it’s not bad…but looking at yours I think I might have to do it all over again.

@Craig:

(You’d think that the test playgroup would notice such annoying things as well?)

We playtesters don’t get material from the company, especially not things like plastic parts, containers, etc.

Well…that explains a whole lot of things.
I thought the playtesters would get the actual thing before launch aswell, and there’d be room to adress remarks still.

No wonder. I kept thinking “Why did those playtesters didnt get pissed or frustrated by the lack of <insert all=”" those=“” random=“” issues=“” here=“”>"

Thanks for clearing that up.</insert>

No these containers will not all fit inside the original  box.  They are each about the side of a generic hard cover book.

I agree it would be awesome if they all fit inside the box - like the old Styrofoam containers .  However, I now have the luxury of having a 94"x44" permanent war gaming table and I intend on leaving most of the game components out on that table, thus these boxes will work perfectly because I’ll have virtually no need to ever put the game or compents back in the original box.  :evil:

We he said they got the rules and Map files from Larry.  That doesn’t mean that when WOTC drew them up/typed them up for printing in the factory that they copied them over correctly.  And you never know, maybe they were using 1980s word processing software with no spell check to save $$$ on corporate Microsoft Office licenses.

@Brain:

@Craig:

(You’d think that the test playgroup would notice such annoying things as well?)

We playtesters don’t get material from the company, especially not things like plastic parts, containers, etc.  We have to use whatever we already have.  We just get the rules and map files from Larry and go from there.

Well at least you could have fixed the rules.

I wonder with what setup they played. Major IC & Minor IC for Anzac?

@Xayd74:

Woodstock - The 1984 A&A, which wasn’t actually the original, had white styrofoam containers, not dissimilar than my solution. They were very fragile and didnt fit the poker chips very well, but it was a good design for sure. The original game was released in 1981 by Nova Game Designs, although I’ve never seen that edition. Thank you for the compliment! I was very pleased with the results myself.

Sorry 'bout the error about the original (Heck, I’m from 1982, my bro got the game in '89, so Im allowed to make mistakes :)  )
As for fragilness (sp?): Those white styrofoam containers still are intact, and that after +20 years of usage. I actually don’t see that happening with the paper containers now included.
As for the poker chips…these fit perfectly in the containers we had?

Oh well…doesn’t matter anyways…it still amazes me how WoTC craps up like this in every single version of A&A that I bought.

@Craig:

We concentrated on our work as it related to the Europe and Global rules and map.  I think that we did a good job of making sure things are in good shape for those games.

Have you seen the official map??  ;)