@toblerone77:
Off topic but LH you might like Memoir’44. It plays like and is designed by Richard Borg the designer of Battle Cry.
I must also tip my hat to you also. I’ve suggested it myself as a reason for custom pieces, but I believe you’ve mentioned it as a primary reason, is the simple esthetics of custom pieces.
I have never played Memoir '44, though I have looked it over in stores. I would not be opposed to playing it, its just that I do not have the desire to go out and buy it as yet. Is my impression correct that it is more tactical than globally strategic? As in A&A D-Day (or smaller) versus A&A G40?
As for the aesthetics of the pieces, I totally agree! That is the main reason I buy them. I have always wanted to have a very technically accurate miniature force to push around the board. For someone who studies WWII vehicle and personnel reference books for fun, OOB pieces are quite droll and pathetically detailed. My intent is to paint all of the pieces I am buying from HBG, something I really love doing, even though it has been some time since I did any painting.
@knp7765:
Hey LHoffman,
You should try out my variant of Global 40 where the French join Germany and Italy as a new Axis partner. For one thing, they don’t get taken out round 1 so you actually get to buy stuff with France. Imagine Dunkurque Battleships and Bearn Carriers roaming the Atlantic and Med. Char B1 tanks lumbering across the battlefield. D.520 fighter streaking through the air.
One reason I like YGs Delta and/or Halifax rules is the changes they bring to G40. I have not actually played either yet, but I am hoping they diversify gameplay from the ruts we sometimes find ourselves in when playing OOB G40/2nd Ed. It may eventually be that people will find the best paths to victory and again get into ruts and paths of doing things, but I think this may be inevitable.
As for your version… it sounds compelling. As much as I really don’t care much for French pieces, I would love to see them used more… especially the ships, I love ships. I would like to see some variant wherein Germany can commandeer French units (esp. ships) or convert them to German units.
One question I have is how your version plays in terms of balance? Theoretically, it might not sway balance issues too much since France is just spending the IPCs that Germany would have or would spend when they conquer France. There could be Axis advantages in having an extra Power in the turn cycle… However, this also weakens Germany in that they have far fewer IPCs to spend against the USSR… plus they forfeit any bonuses they might get from French territories.
It is a very interesting concept. And it does give an excuse to use the French pieces for a change.