I have another idea:
If it is announced that AAP40 and AAE40 are limited editions, you can raise money by selling them.
It may be a bit of a pain, but it’s an honest way to raise money ( you are trading something for something else)
Buy them on pre-order and sell them for $200 latter. But you need to wait till the official word gets out.
People will buy from you more than another because: 1) they are supporting the site, 2) you sell them for a little under the market rate.
Now that Christmas approach is the best time to do something. High quality jackets, polo shirts, Hats, etc…
Just one logo makes it a simple choice.
Id look into contacting WOTC customer service, get the banners that they display for AA50 and AAp40 You sell them and split profit with WOTC? Have Larry sign a couple of them and auction on ebay?
Larry will listen to you and give you some advice because it is in his interest to promote his games… win/win
I like the badge idea, where donors get some graphic to show they care.
I would make some custom badges for:
Special people:
House rules specialist
AA pieces junkie
Low Luck player
‘What if’ Historian
Play by Forum 2006-9 champ and runner up
I answer rules questions
etc…
Make them cute and tongue in cheek. The badge costs x amount, but subject to awards by you.