• Japan fleets off Brazil and Egypt means wide open Pacific for a mid-game USA move against Japan (see most of Darth’s games for an example of the mid game USA Pacific move).


  • Scenario: it’s around turn 6. Japan had just taken New Zealand having there 1tra+1inf or 2, 1car+2ftr, 1BB.
    US has started to heavily KGF with a 5+5 transport fleet, has main fleet in Baltic, only 5 transports in SZ08 (SW of Britain) - enough to deter a lone German bomber - and say 3 fighters in Karelia.

    Is this early warning of Japan in NZ strong enough for US to switch to some preventive anti-Japan building ? What would that best be ?

    • Extra fighters built in EEU - reducing inf+arty flows ?
    • Taking (some) fleet out of Baltic ? But that would mean dividing the (ships-vs-German-air) defense in 3. The Channel area is targetable by German fighters in addition to the bomber. So that may mean needing to take fighters out of Karelia to land on US or UK carrier. What if these fighters were NOW critical to hold the forward European presence ?
    • Specific anti-ship units (offensive: sub, defensive and projection: carrier)

    The “opportunity cost” problem arises because Japan can’t do very much with the 2car,2BB,1des in an anti-Russia effort not opposed by US KJF. So they may use them “somewhere” essentially for free. Brazil is one possibility, Alaskan raid or Africa others…

  • '18 '17 '16 '11 Moderator

    Hobbes,

    I had Japan invade Brazil, build an IC and start invasions of W. Indies and later E. USA.

    My opponent wasn’t the sharpest stick in the world, but it was a fun game!

  • 2007 AAR League

    I find that the Jap fleet can be very helpful in bombarding Egypt / Persia / Trans-Jordan etc.

    Also, if you can get some units through the Suez in time, it can really prolong the life of the German fleet in the Med.

  • '18 '17 '16 '11 Moderator

    No disagreement here.

    After Africa is secure, though, pushing through with the Japanese fleet can be a wise decision since it threatens the American shuck and the British shuck usually forcing them to pull their airforces back or build warships or both.


  • I find that the Jap fleet can be very helpful in bombarding Egypt / Persia / Trans-Jordan etc.

    I think this is something very interesting to investigate. Use 2 transports and shuck units from the Indian complex into these areas to up the pressure on the Allies? The Japanese have 2 bbs and a big airforce to spend in Africa while the Allies don’t really want to spend all day in there with the Germans on their minds.

  • '18 '17 '16 '11 Moderator

    No use investigating this, it’s pretty much standard operating procedure.

    Though, I’d like to investigate the potential of sailing the Japanese fleet around the Cape of Good Hope (think that’s the one) off the coast of S. Africa and going up to SZ 12 to spit in the face of the allies. =)

    Better make sure you keep some cash in reserve to throw down a fleet in SZ 60 if America get’s fancy though.


  • Japan fleet in the Atlantic is only an issue of the UK is LOCKED into landings in Archangel.  Otherwise, it is a suicide move for Japan.


  • Well I can’t say I would have a whole lot of fun with the Japanese fleet threatening the shuck fleet going from E. Canada to London. It’s probably suicide to try to go after the advance fleet which has all the US and Uk combo in there, but the support fleet is not that well defended usually.


  • Perhaps with some players, not with me…


  • Well even if it was poorly defended you would pretty much need to have 4 fighters with your Japanese fleet to get something done, which is a pretty big waste of resources IMO sailing so far off when your fighters could be used to threaten Moscow, trade Africa, or defend territories.

  • '18 '17 '16 '11 Moderator

    Well, 2 Battleships, 2 or 3 Destroyers, a half dozen submarines, a couple of fodder transports and 4 fighters in the Atlantic under Japanese control at the very least would dictate a response from the allies.  Otherwise, SZ’s 1 and 10 get blockaded ending the American influence in the war.  Sure, the Combined Allied Fleet might survive a direct assault, but no one said the Japanese need to attack the Allies.  They just have to get in the way, right?


  • If Japan is THAT heavy in the Atlantic, then the Allies are sitting pretty, because Japan is pitifully weak in Africa, Asia, and the Indian Ocean… not to mention ripe for a US PACFLT…

  • '18 '17 '16 '11 Moderator

    @ncscswitch:

    If Japan is THAT heavy in the Atlantic, then the Allies are sitting pretty, because Japan is pitifully weak in Africa, Asia, and the Indian Ocean… not to mention ripe for a US PACFLT…

    As I said, Japan has to hold some cash in reserve to plop down a navy in SZ 60 if America decides to get fancy and try to put a transport in SZ 55 for free island grabbing.

    If Japan is THAT heavy in the Atlantic, then the Allies are doomed, because the Allies are absent from Africa, Asia and the Indian Ocean AND their main life line to Russia is severed reducing Allied reinforcements to expensive fighters and bombers and giving the Germans a reprieve from allied one two punches to European landings.

    After all, it’s relatively cheap to put two existing fighters on a carrier in SZ 60 and sink whatever America puts in SZ 55 with the loss of 1 or 2 fighters.  Much more expensive for America to build a Carrier, 2 Fighters, Transport(s) and submarines to start to make a threat in the empty Pacific.  Not to mention, that’s 2 or 3 rounds of expenditures in the Pacific while Japan clears up the American and British fleets or locks them in SZ 4/5 while the Germans and Japanese kill off Moscow.

  • 2007 AAR League

    Umm - I don’t think that a Japan fleet sufficient to guard a TRN off Brazil is necessarily a strong enough fleet to wipe out the UK and US fleets - both of which are much more quickly reinforced in the atlantic than the Japanese fleet.

    BTW, Jennifer, when are you going to shorten your sig? It’s a bit long, and I’m tired of reading Ivanova’s ranting and raving.


  • I think Japan moving in the Atlantic might be a good one,

    Not really to attack, but just show your shining white teeth to let them watch their moves twice, and give Germany some hope on a bette rnavy (if needed) Mostly the German fleet is doomed, if not correctly handled and a bit luck, or just no Allied force attacking.

    Going for Brazil, and/or Africa with your navy might sound nice, stick them into S17, this is just out of range from Washington, but you can reach: S7, S8, S9, S11, S12, S19, even Paris and London are in reach of you,
    Only problem: if you placed an IC in Brazil, you need to move first to that one to continue your move.

    I think I could try this one, but it needs lots of patience to act wisely there, and I doubt if an IC is the solution,
    Not quiet sure.


  • I’m a fan of banging up Africa with the Japanese navy =D


  • I usually try to get Australia and then move to Madagascar and then Africa with part of the Japanese fleet, leaving the other part in sz60.
    A fast raid in Brazil, with Africa fleet may divert USA attention from Europe.
    The problem is that Japan should not divert too much ships from sz60 so it is not “safe” to stay in Atlantic.


  • @Romulus:

    I usually try to get Australia and then move to Madagascar and then Africa with part of the Japanese fleet, leaving the other part in sz60.
    A fast raid in Brazil, with Africa fleet may divert USA attention from Europe.
    The problem is that Japan should not divert too much ships from sz60 so it is not “safe” to stay in Atlantic.

    True,

    You should keep enough backed-up in the Pacific, around Tokyo. (a few transports, 2 destroyers submarine might sound good enough?)


  • Ideally I try to preserve the Japanese fleet a s long as possible.
    So usually I try to let in sz60 at least 1 AC and 1 BB. The cruise to Australia and then to Africa is executed by the other BB and the other AC.
    If Japan have only 1 BB and 1 AC, then 1 DD and as many Subs is possible have the task to defend sz60.
    If Japan have less than 1 BB and 1 AC there is little hope of being able to go to Australia and then Africa…  :-D

Suggested Topics

  • 30
  • 17
  • 18
  • 25
  • 8
  • 3
  • 7
  • 4
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

75

Online

17.5k

Users

40.1k

Topics

1.7m

Posts