@Kaladesh:
back to the NA ;-)
fugo sounds interesting indeed ;-) a good oportunitiy to harass us and prepare for an invasion into us ;-)
however i still do not like the kamikaze version.
hitting a capitalship for sure does inbalance the start in my view. now japan could surely destroy the ac in pearl harbour in j1 with a single plane. us would be forced to have their ac and bb together (which would not be the problem) but since japan has its first round before us the attack on pearl harbour would be “standard” … after that this kamikaze would probably become useless since the us would hold its capitalships together. even 2 planes (20 ipc) can destroy the bb (24 ipc). thats a bit too strong to me. at least the enemy fighters may have a chance of hunting down this kamikaze right before they hit the ship. but then kamikaze would be useless as well.
i could not figure out a rule how this kamikaze might become useful but not too strong :-/
and to the dreadnoughts … i already stated it that i belive 5/5 to be to strong as well. 3hit bb or opening fire first round only (due to the larger range of their guns before entering the actual battle) may be a bit more ballanced (and i still believe that japan does not have the ipc to produce a bb early on and if they have enough later, than they might be on the winning run anyways).
the rest goes fine with me :-)
btw. i like to play japan but in my view those two things are a bit overpowered.
The chance to sink a BB with two kamikazes is 44% (0,66*0,66)! And that is if The BB is alone, otherwise one can always pick a hit on a second BB!
About the AC in Pearl Harbor in J1, the fighter on board can land on Hawaii! That means a cost of 16 IPCs (AC) at a chance of 66% compared to the sure cost of 10 IPCs. That is some 10,7 IPCs in damage on average, compared to the cost of 10 IPCs for Japan! Not to tempting I guess, but worth a try I guess!
I still think the BB variant with opening fire first round only is stronger than the 5/5 variant! About the 3 hit BB I am not sure, however it could compensate for the U.S. cheap cannon fodder, namely Liberty Ship Program! Lets see how the poll will come out! The poll will be my law in this case!
One might think that the kamikazes should be used to keep U.S. at bay at all costs, to buy time for the Asian campaign! When that is done Japan have made some extra IPCs that can compensate for the lost fighters and maybe Japan stands a good chance of giving the Russians a hard match! If Japan also have New Zealand and Australia, there is an even bigger incentive to keep U.S. at bay with kamikazes! :wink: