• @knp7765:

    So in your example of 2 inf, 1 ftr attacking 1 inf,  you just roll 1 dice for the attackers and try to get a 5 or less?  Instead of rolling 2 dice for a “1” and 1 dice for a “3”.  And the 1 defending inf simply rolls 1 dice for a “2”.  This doesn’t seem fair to the defender.  It’s much easier to get a 5 or less with 1 dice than it is to get a 1 rolling 2 dice or a 3 or less with 1 dice.

    Low Luck favors both the attacker and the defender, as long as you have more than 1 unit present. Single units facing 2 or more units will always be at a disadvantage, in the example above the chance of the attackers missing the 5 roll is 17% with LL, while the odds of missing 1 hit with 3 regular dice rolls are 35%. If the defender had 2 infantry his chances of missing with a single roll of 4 or less on LL are 33% while with regular dice they are 44% for both rolls missing.

  • Sponsor

    I must have killed this thread when I changed the title…… Sorry.


  • No worries grasshopper there really wasn’t much left to talk about. I am on R7 in my game right now and US is about to push Japan out of phillipines, but they can’t hold it, yet.


  • Well, nobody really debated the best US purchase anyhow… maybe it was worth killing…  :)

  • Sponsor

    @theROCmonster:

    No worries grasshopper there really wasn’t much left to talk about. I am on R7 in my game right now and US is about to push Japan out of phillipines, but they can’t hold it, yet.

    **IT’S ROUND 7 AND THE AMERICANS ARE JUST KICKING THE JAPS OUT OF THE PHILIPPINES NOW?

    MY GOD MAN!! WHAT HAVE YOUR YANKS BEEN DOING, AND WHERE THE HELL HAVE THEY BEEN DOING IT?

    DO YOUR AMERICANS REALIZE THAT THEY ARE GIVING UP A $5 NO EVERY ROUND THEY SPEND SURFING IN SYDNEY?**

  • '18 '17 '16 '11 Moderator

    @Young:

    @theROCmonster:

    No worries grasshopper there really wasn’t much left to talk about. I am on R7 in my game right now and US is about to push Japan out of phillipines, but they can’t hold it, yet.

    **IT’S ROUND 7 AND THE AMERICANS ARE JUST KICKING THE JAPS OUT OF THE PHILIPPINES NOW?

    MY GOD MAN!! WHAT HAVE YOUR YANKS BEEN DOING, AND WHERE THE HELL HAVE THEY BEEN DOING IT?

    DO YOUR AMERICANS REALIZE THAT THEY ARE GIVING UP A $5 NO EVERY ROUND THEY SPEND SURFING IN SYDNEY?**

    They were probably going “oh sh!t!!!” and trying to stop Germany for a few rounds after London fell.


  • No japan built fleet every round with america. 7-9 subs a turn with Japan. I don’t think you understand how hard it is for Japan to get knocked out of the phillipines. US is 3 turns away from the phillipines at San francisco and Japan is only 1 turn away. Yes US has Naval dominance, but it is this 3 turns aways VS. 1 turn away that makes it tough.


  • I haven’t bought a single transport for the US and right now I have 25 subs, 6 destroyers, 3 cruisers, 3 carriers fully loaded, and 1 BB stationed off of queensland with US and 10 subs in hawaii and 7 subs 2 destroyers and a fully loaded carrier in san francisco. I have been trading off a destroyer for a sub every turn with Japan with US loosing a destroyer. On T3 Japan blocked and lost 2 destroyers, but got good rolls and US lost the 2 subs it sent to kill the destroyers, but they did kill the Jap destroyers. So I don’t see how in the world you are saying that US can walk all over Japan so early. You must be playing poor opponets. I am not some noob player grasshopper. I haven’t lost a game of revised or 42 version in over 50 games… I am 6-0 right now in global… Japan on T2 built 2 subs 2 DD’s T3 built 5 subs, and on T4 built 8 subs. and now Japan has 22 subs, 6 destroyers, 2 cruisers, 5 carriers, 22 planes, and 2 BB’s. Next turn I can put 22 subs, 6 DD’s, 2 cruisers, 5 carriers, 13 planes (3 for airbase), and 2 BB’s in the phillipines.

  • Sponsor

    Cool down kojak, I was just messin with you, but now I see that your numbers are off… How can you be questioning my opponents if your winning so many games in a row? Don’t you think that’s a little piculuar? 25 subs? 16 destroyers? 22 planes? Sounds to me like your afraid to attack yourself. In my thread that started this whole thing, I said that my first US purchase was a battleship and 2 carriers, in another thread I laid out 4 complete US rounds in a move detailed blueprint explaining a strategy of mine that you called hog wash right from the get go, but since then I have had one experienced member try it and took back the Phillipenes and sunk the Japanese fleet way before round 7, and it doesn’t entail stacking or turtling. My strategy also called for the movement of my entire fleet during peace time to consolidate off the coast of queensland, so when America enters the war, they are in perfect position to take back the island. Besides, if you played my strategy move for move with my blueprint, where’s my second battleship in the pacific, I bought one and I started with one, and if you tell me that I lost it to low luck rolls trying to break through a destroyer blocking the Phillipenes, than I must be a fool. That reminds me… how can you beat your chest at me with your unbeaten record when only last week we established that you didn’t even know what round the Americans where able to declare war? You got Japan taking all the Dutch islands and making over $60 buying nothing but a ton of subs and destroyers, and all this before J3. My record would be 20-0 too if I could get away with that, but seriously let’s stop bashing each other, at least until I get the time to watch all your videos and find out what rules your playing by. BTW, I laid out a UK#1 strategy in the same thread, don’t suppose you followed that one to kick Italian butt?


  • Ok so instead of having 2 more subs and 1 more destroyer you will have 1 more BB. Still doesn’t mean you can attack my fleet. If you do you will loose horribly. The reason the moves are so defensive is because I am playing LL and if US attacked Japan would win with all her carriers and BB’s left and then some planes as well. US will be decimated while japan can then just repair her ships and buy more planes…

  • Sponsor

    @theROCmonster:

    Ok so instead of having 2 more subs and 1 more destroyer you will have 1 more BB. Still doesn’t mean you can attack my fleet. If you do you will loose horribly. The reason the moves are so defensive is because I am playing LL and if US attacked Japan would win with all her carriers and BB’s left and then some planes as well. US will be decimated while japan can then just repair her ships and buy more planes…

    Your missing the point I have been trying to make since the dawn of this conversation, which is…… My goal is to lose all my capital ships, destroyers, fighters, subs, strategic bombers and full transpots, in order to sink the Jap navy and leave 1 infantry on the phillipenes. That’s what my strategy aims to do, to make a clean slate on the ocean surface by sending everything to the ocean floor by the end of US#5. Than we will see who can out spend who.


  • You also seem to be missing mine grasshopper. Japan can Defend against US doing this. Once the battle is said and done with Japan will have 3 carriers and 2 BB’s left that can be repaired… This is a lot of money that america will now to have to contend with and Japan will still have a bunch of planes left. Attrition battles work when there aren’t units that can be left and repaired. 3 Carriers and 2 bb’s is 88 dollars worth of units.

  • Sponsor

    Your forgeting about the ANZAC units that are going to mop up those limping ships.


  • I don’t see it. We’ll have to play sometime in the future and I can show you my Japan I am talking about.


  • Also the US can’t take the phillipines if they don’t win the sea battle, which in low luck it is impossible.


  • Young Grasshopper  (or is i@Young:

    @theROCmonster:

    Ok so instead of having 2 more subs and 1 more destroyer you will have 1 more BB. Still doesn’t mean you can attack my fleet. If you do you will loose horribly. The reason the moves are so defensive is because I am playing LL and if US attacked Japan would win with all her carriers and BB’s left and then some planes as well. US will be decimated while japan can then just repair her ships and buy more planes…

    Your missing the point I have been trying to make since the dawn of this conversation, which is…… My goal is to lose all my capital ships, destroyers, fighters, subs, strategic bombers and full transpots, in order to sink the Jap navy and leave 1 infantry on the phillipenes. That’s what my strategy aims to do, to make a clean slate on the ocean surface by sending everything to the ocean floor by the end of US#5. Than we will see who can out spend who.

    Young Grave chopper would be a good new nickname ;)

    Just for the record: have you played as Japan against your own blueprint?

  • Sponsor

    To be honest not yet, the wife is gone today so I was just about to go down stairs and stare at my table for hours. 1 game, my US opponent setup in Queens land during peace time and it worried me, but for some reason he moved everything back to Hawaii and started stacking, I was very relieved (I guess some habits are hard to break).


  • I just put up my latest video showing what the board currently looks like in round 7 it the end of Russia’s R7.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8gPRXDdcV4

  • Sponsor

    My cat just destroyed my table which had a setup from a saved game, dam, forgot to shut the door into my game room.


  • @theROCmonster:

    I just put up my latest video showing what the board currently looks like in round 7 it the end of Russia’s R7.

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=R8gPRXDdcV4

    Waw, that’s a big UK fleet, i’m jealous!
    Most of the big fights still need to take place, it seems.

    By the way, i know it’s easy to say but try to keep the camera abit steady ;)

Suggested Topics

  • 5
  • 6
  • 53
  • 18
  • 17
  • 15
  • 8
  • 6
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

108

Online

17.5k

Users

40.1k

Topics

1.7m

Posts