@coachdcj Player 2 is correct. From the Official Rules Clarifications document (page 4):
You can never give an ally anything: units, territories or I.P.C.'s.
I have a Question, how does amphibious assaults work if the trannies are involved in naval combats the same turn I’m confused :x
You must do any naval combat before you unload any troops off the trannies. So, assuming your transports survive they are free to unload their cargo, however you get NO Battleship (if you have one) shot because it used up its turn in the naval combat.
Any trans taken as casualties during the naval combat are sunk and their cargo is lost, so be careful. And after naval combat the trans can no longer move, they can just unload.
A good example is a G1 assault on Egypt:
Ger brings in BB and tran with 2 inf vs. UK sub in E. Med SZ. If the UK sub hits and you lose the tran you also lose the men, so in that case you are almost forced to lose the BB assuming it hit the sub.
what do you mean by how many?
what’s the point of the poll?
the point if the poll is to organize for anarchy
and remember we cheat the other guy and pass the savings on to you :D
also, moral victories dont count :-?
you are one confusing hombre
oh I have much, much more wisdom if you are interested
that I can easily retrieve from my mono-media files (opposed to milti-media) ie. text 8)
7 and 5 are tied!