• @Brain:

    If Russia is eliminated early, then Germany would have only one front to contend with.

    Ehhhh… If Germany starts the game with one foot in France it’d kinda be folly to go after Russia at game start, especially if they’re at peace.

    I’m guessing whatever Germany builds in the first three turns is what she’ll have available for Russia when war is imminent.

    But, yeah, IF Germany had been able to somehow get around Poland and the French and English guarantees of war dec with the Polish invasion in 1939, THEN she would have had full confidence of the West in invading and conquering Soviet Russia.  I think if Germany had gone after "Anchluss"ing German citizens and German land in Poland FIRST instead of Czechoslovakia she might have gotten away with it under appeasement with Chamberlain.  BAM.  Legal (well almost legal) road to invasion of Russia without promises of Allied war declaration intact.

    Of course, Germany would have been short of several tanks and munitions factories she annexed from Czechoslovakia, but at least the road would have been open.


  • Don’t get all historical on me Mr. Blitz, I am strictly talking game strategy here.


  • We should make a thread that only includes history discussions so we don’t have them going on everywhere


  • @bennyboyg:

    We should make a thread that only includes history discussions so we don’t have them going on everywhere

    We do, it’s in other forums called, imagine this, World War II History:

    http://www.axisandallies.org/forums/index.php?board=57.0


  • Well then it should be used correctly then!


  • @bennyboyg:

    Well then it should be used correctly then!

    Somehow, history always gets mixed up in most of the discussion here, because A&A is a historical game, or I should say loosely based on a historical event.


  • Well, that’s because the game is supposed to follow history as closely as possible while also

    1. Not forcing the players to make the same decisions (but encouraging them a bit)
      and
    2. Ensuring balance and fairness, an element not completely in line with history

  • Thats typically how n00bs think. The axis can win. And they frequently do if Germany builds a navy and keeps Americas  hands out of Europe.


  • @xzorn:

    Well, that’s because the game is supposed to follow history as closely as possible while also

    1. Not forcing the players to make the same decisions (but encouraging them a bit)
      and
    2. Ensuring balance and fairness, an element not completely in line with history

    I agree completely.


  • @i:

    well if you want to replay the war then axis always lose allies always win.

    That is why the game can never be too consumed with being exactly like history. Changes have to be made to give each player a fair chance at winning and the freedom to make different dicisions than what the historical leaders did.

Suggested Topics

  • 3
  • 14
  • 8
  • 3
  • 24
  • 24
  • 12
  • 25
Axis & Allies Boardgaming Custom Painted Miniatures

67

Online

17.4k

Users

39.9k

Topics

1.7m

Posts