I take a cue from the post for a question: what is the difference between “Av unit left” (attack or defend) and “Unit left if won”? maybe it’s a trivial question but …
Anyone know how TripleA calculates survivors?
-
I’m curious if anyone knows how TripleA counts survivors in the case when you have units that will be automatically killed. As an example, let’s say I attack a SZ that has 2 Carriers + 4 Fighters in it, and if the Carriers are sunk, there is no adjacent coastal territory in which the Fighters can land. If I run the battle calculator and it tells me that the defenders will win 50% of the time with 1 unit left, should I assume that the last unit is a Carrier or a Fighter? If it is likely to be a Fighter, then I might want to make the attack no matter what since I know in every likely scenario all of the enemy units in the SZ will be lost.
The same situation arises when you attack a SZ holding enemy Transports. If the reported survivors on defense is less than the number of TTs, then do I assume that these are all TTs which will be eliminated, or would these be warships plus all the TTs?
-
Remember the calculator is simply calculating the odds of victory or loss based on casualties from weakest to strongest in attack or defense value. meaning it is removing the weakest units first followed by better ones later.
So in your first example the carriers (from the computers perspective) would be the first units to be removed in a hypothetical (a computer generated battle calc. scenario). However, if it were as you described then your opponent would not be taking the carriers first as you could then simply retreat after one round of combat and all the fighters would be lost. Therefore in the scenario you described your odds of victory would actually increase due to the fact that some fighters (at least two initially) would have to be taken as casualties prior to removing a carrier otherwise you could simply retreat after the first round of battle and force your opponent to loose un-landable fighters regardless.
In your second scenario the Transports are considered normal units unless you are playing a game where transports are non-combat units with no combat value at all. In a situation where you are playing with transports that are not combat units then they would be omitted from the battle calculator. So if the defender is being shown as winning, then those survivors would be only the combat units. Transports would be in addition to those numbers. Now if the transports are combat units (meaning they have defense values) then they would be included in the Battle calculator. However, since the Battle calculator would, in this scenario, be accounting for them it would also be removing them first as casualties since they are the weakest units. If your opponent decides to keep them and take other combat units as casualties first, then you are likely to have better odds of either causing more casualties or winning the battle.
At the end of the day the Battle calc. is good for basic odds of victory or defeat and the number of surviving units. It does not take anything else into consideration. You still have to put some thought towards your maneuvers, possible changes in casualty selection by your opponent and also whether you are playing LL (low luck) or Dice.
-
Remember the calculator is simply calculating the odds of victory or loss based on casualties from weakest to strongest in attack or defense value. meaning it is removing the weakest units first followed by better ones later.
That’s about what I suspected, thanks!
Suggested Topics
