R1 Japan attack India sea

[GeZe]

Yanny, it would not be there as the rule is in the Rule Clarafications

[Guest]

What you are saying GeZe is that it is illegal for a carrier to move with the fighters on it and then launch the fighters. This I agree with. But in this case, the fighters are off the carrier before the carrier moves, because it isn’t moving. Then, after all is said and done, it moves into range for the fighters to land on it. Which is legal.

[GeZe]

but both are the same thing, one the carrier goes first the other the fighter goes first

[cystic crypt]

no
when the ftr goes - that’s combat
when the ac goes, that’s non-combat.
when the ftr lands, that too is non-combat.

[GeZe]

OK, I give up :x