@Gargantua:

Medium luck is the best thing that anyone ever came up with to address this.

anytime you are about to roll dice you can choose - Average + remainder die, or all dice.

It makes a hell of a better game, and most of the time, you find that you risk in on the dice anyways!

Thanks for bringing this up.  I’ve never tried medium luck before.  It seems like a good way to balance out the pros/cons of playing either way.  I’ll be sure to try this in my next game.

Thanks for the answers guys.  I personally prefer low luck because I think it takes away a little bit of the frustration from losing something just because of bad dice rolls.  If you do well you can give yourself credit, and if you do poorly there is nothing to blame but yourself.

Also explain why you use whichever one you picked.

Edit: added medium luck as an option in the poll

Hello everyone, i’m completely new to these forums but have been playing Axis and Allies for a long time now.  I’m curious to see what you guys think will be done with the new game to capture the feeling of the trench warfare on the western front.