But the benefit is also positional. The allies don’t want axis units running around in the Atlantic able to escape and perform a dash to the Medd, or worst around Cape Horn and mess with UK Indian fleet.
For the axis, they just killed most of the British navy on G1, now another navy turned for UK making that race easier for allies.
Just dealing with the land and air would almost cut out all the funny things that go on in games.
But we just got to playtest the rule that was proposed by Oztea. Thats the bottom line.
also i think the disposition should be final after the first roll…. rolling every turn makes the rules even more subject to glitching.
1 - Replace with UK unit
2 - Scuttled
3 - Stays French (roll again next turn)
4 - Stays French (roll again next turn)
5 - Scuttled
6 - Replace with German unit
3 and 4 should be Vichy and that’s it without any further rolling. Vichy naval goto protect Vichy areas or be interned at Dakar ( FWA). If FWA is attacked the fleet is released to fight the enemy, and FWA is not convertible under diplomacy rules ( too much at stake).
FCA and FEA are Free French ( pro allies).